No 4 (2025)
Articles
Transformation of the idea of the separation of powers in non-classical legal traditions: Islamic and Confucian approaches in the context of constitutional law.
Abstract
In the context of the global influence of Islamic and Confucian legal traditions, the traditional doctrine of the separation of powers developed by Locke and Montesquieu can no longer be viewed as universal and indispensable. Contemporary constitutional systems of several countries demonstrate fundamentally different ways of distributing the functions of public authority that go beyond the classical triad of legislative, executive, and judicial branches. This transformation is particularly evident in Islamic states, where Sharia is integrated into the basis of power, and in China, where Confucian ideals of moral leadership intertwine with the party-state vertical. The theoretical and legal challenge lies in defining the limits of applicability of the Western model and identifying mechanisms for its adaptation or substitution in non-classical conditions. The subject of the study is, in fact, the process of transforming the idea of separation of powers into constitutional and legal mechanisms of Islamic and Confucian traditions. The work analyzes how these legal systems construct a balance of power relying not on the competition of branches but on ethical-religious and moral-philosophical foundations. Special attention is paid to comparing formal constitutional norms and the actual practice of public governance. The study employs a comparative legal method that allows for the identification of universal and local elements of institutional models. A hermeneutic approach is applied to the analysis of philosophical-legal texts of the "Lunyu," Sharia treatises, and constitutional norms. Novelty of the research and conclusions. For the first time, the concept of a "non-classical triad" is formulated, wherein the functions of public authority are redistributed through sacralized mechanisms rather than through formal checks and balances. It is shown that in Islamic states, the supremacy of divine sovereignty (hakimiyya) transforms the notions of legislative and executive power into a single system of divinely ordained legitimacy. In the Chinese paradigm, the role of Confucian principles of "合" (unity) and "德" (virtue) is identified as substitutes for the competition of branches of power. The practice of institutional acculturation is described, allowing for the borrowing of the separation of powers on simultaneously adapted and hybrid grounds. It is established that the lack of formal channels for internal criticism is compensated for by mechanisms of moral control and party discipline. The study confirms that non-classical legal traditions possess their own, self-sufficient tools for balancing power that do not reduce to the Western system of checks and balances.
Politics and Society. 2025;(4):1-20
1-20
Legal regulation of the use of genomic technologies in agriculture: the evolution of approaches in foreign law
Abstract
This article is devoted to a comprehensive analysis of current trends and challenges in the legal regulation of agrobiotechnology in the context of the global transition from classical transgenesis to site-directed genome editing technologies such as CRISPR-Cas9. The relevance of the study is due to the rapid development of these technologies, which offer new opportunities for food security, climate change adaptation and sustainable agricultural development, but face diverse and often outdated legal regimes. The aim of the work is to identify and systematize key models of legal regulation of the turnover of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) and genomic editing products in countries that are leading producers of agricultural products, as well as features, common features and patterns in the development of legal regulation in this area using the example of the agricultural sector. Based on the comparative legal method, the legal systems of the United States, Canada, Brazil, Argentina, the European Union, China, India, and the Russian Federation in this area have been studied. The analysis made it possible to identify three dominant regulatory approaches: a product-oriented model (USA, Canada), a flexible model stimulating innovation (Brazil, Argentina), and a model based on strict application of the precautionary principle (EU, China, India, Russia). Special attention is paid to the legal status of organisms obtained using genome editing technologies that do not contain foreign DNA. Recent legislative initiatives aimed at differentiating their regulation from classical GMOs, in particular, the new EU Regulation on new Genomic techniques (NGTs), have been investigated. In conclusion, the main trends are summarized, which include the transition from regulating the creation process to evaluating the characteristics of the final product, as well as the formation of simplified procedures for genome editing products. It is revealed that the lack of international harmonization in this area remains the main barrier to the development of innovation. It is concluded that it is necessary to develop a detailed and balanced regulatory framework in Russia that would ensure biosafety without hindering scientific and technological progress in the agricultural sphere.
Politics and Society. 2025;(4):21-34
21-34
Artificial Intelligence as a Tool for Selective Migration Policy: Methodology, Effectiveness, and Socio-Cultural Consequences
Abstract
In the context of growing global mobility and increasing migration challenges, states are increasingly resorting to digital technologies to optimize migration management. In this context, artificial intelligence (AI) is transforming from an auxiliary tool into a central element of selective migration policy, providing strategic selection of migrants based on predictive analytics and big data. The article analyzes specific examples of AI implementation in migration systems, such as ETIAS in the EU, USCIS in the US, and the Global Talent Visa in the UK, demonstrating the shift from bureaucratic procedures to algorithmic management. The author shows that, despite increased operational efficiency and analytical power, the widespread use of AI is associated with significant ethical and socio-cultural risks: algorithmic discrimination, opacity of decisions ("black boxes"), the formation of "digital inequality," and the dehumanization of the migration process. The methodological foundation of the study consists of general logical techniques of the dialectical method (analysis, comparison), methods of systemic analysis, and algorithmic management. The main results of the study are as follows. Special attention is paid to the problem of reproducing historical biases through training models on biased data, which leads to the systematic marginalization of migrants from certain regions. Since algorithms are trained on archives of past decisions, they can reinforce colonial stereotypes, selective practices, and ethnic stereotypes, transforming them into "objective" assessments of risk or integration potential. The article emphasizes the need for an interdisciplinary reflexive approach, in which migration studies, as an integrative humanitarian discipline, takes on the role of a control mechanism capable of exposing the hidden ideologies of algorithms and protecting the rights of migrants. It is argued that only the combination of technological innovations with ethical frameworks, such as the OECD principles on AI and the provisions of European regulation on artificial intelligence, and the recognition of migrant agency, will preserve migration as a space of freedom rather than turn it into a technocratic filtering procedure.
Politics and Society. 2025;(4):35-45
35-45
Value Priorities of The Modern Indonesian Elite As Constructive Factors In The Formation of National Mentality And Political Identity
Abstract
The object of this study is the mental transformations associated with the formation of a unified national mentality. The subject of the research is the value orientations of the contemporary political and cultural elite of the Republic of Indonesia. The aim of the work is to analyze the value priorities of the contemporary Indonesian elite as constructive factors in the formation of national mentality and political identity. An understanding of the peculiarities of identity formation in Indonesia is provided. Factors of its formation, such as migration, the struggle for liberation, and the ideology of Pancasila, are reflected. The cultural specificity of Indonesian society is demonstrated as the interaction of regional cultures in Indonesia and the cultures of other countries. The processes of assimilation and acculturation are reflected. It is shown that ethnic diversity is a source of problems in the process of formation of the national mentality of Indonesians. A definition of mentality is provided. The substantive content of the phenomenon of mentality by Indonesian politicians is revealed. The methodological basis of the study was the mental approach (O. V. Kolesova), which makes it possible to interpret mentality as a structure including biological, psychological, social, and cultural elements. The systems approach (D. Easton) made it possible to present new value orientations of the modern Indonesian elite from the perspective of a system that ensures political priorities. The novelty of the study lies in the following: the political identity of Indonesians is formed under the influence of cultural factors that transform mentality; the formation of national mentality is correlated with the values positioned by the modern Indonesian elite. The vision of Indonesian national identity as perceived by Indonesian leaders is presented. Common aspects are positioned in the understanding of the cultural field as a struggle for various forms of capital and the understanding of identity politics as the competitive positioning of various social groups in the pursuit of preferences. Types of identity criteria are distinguished: economic and cultural. The criteria of identity of Indonesian society are positioned as cultural. The cultural specificity of Indonesians is demonstrated in relation to religious preferences. An understanding of the influence of religion on the formation of political views is provided. The ambivalence of religious identity criteria in Indonesia is revealed. The value orientations of the Indonesian political and cultural elite are identified as constructive factors in the formation of national mentality and political identity. Conclusions are formulated regarding the correspondence of the Indonesian elite's value orientations with the objectives of shaping the national mentality and corresponding political identity. Recommendations are provided for the development of educational and cultural programs aimed at shaping the national mentality and political identity of Indonesians.
Politics and Society. 2025;(4):46-63
46-63
The emergence of the theory of activating social policy and its meaning for solving modern problems of the welfare state
Abstract
The article explores the theory of activating social policy, which emerged in Europe in the late 20th and early 21st centuries to address the growing challenges of the welfare state. The theory's emergence stems from academic and political debates over social policy reforms. Social programs established in the mid- to late 20th century began to create economic and financial problems due to an aging population and increased competition in the context of globalization. The theory of activating social policy proposed to reorient social programs from a compensation-based approach to a preventative approach and investment in human capital. The theory of activating social policy is assessed in the context of other contemporary approaches and research findings, including opportunity theory, analysis of the impact of social reforms on electoral processes, and assessments of the relationship between social reforms, poverty, and inequality. The theory of activating social policy was based on the notion of the high political significance of social programs and the impossibility of radically reducing them due to their popularity among the population. To preserve these programs, it was proposed to increase the efficiency of converting resources into results. The state was supposed to create conditions for the greatest economic productivity of citizens and reduce the burden on social programs from predictable social risks. Measurement of the effectiveness of activating social policy programs in domestic and international studies has shown that these programs are highly effective in supporting the elderly, and moderately or poorly effective in supporting employment and fertility. From a political perspective, countries with activating social programs have an advantage because their costs are lower. From an economic and social perspective, countries with reactive social programs have better results in reducing poverty and inequality.
Politics and Society. 2025;(4):64-79
64-79
Verification of documents confirming education and/or qualifications through a specialized federal information system: legal regulation and law enforcement practice
Abstract
The article is dedicated to the study of the problem of access to information about issued documents on education and/or qualifications, training documents through a specialized federal information system. The topic is relevant because the resource, once put into operation, does not fully meet the tasks for which it was developed. As a result, educational organizations and archival institutions continue to receive requests to confirm the issuance of a document on education and/or qualifications, training documents to the person indicated as the holder. The subject of the research includes the norms of Russian legislation in the field of regulating the functioning of the information system "FRDO," law enforcement practices, as well as the works of domestic legal scholars. The methodological basis of the research consists of general scientific methods (analysis, synthesis, induction, deduction, generalization), as well as specialized legal methods (formal legal). The scientific novelty of the research is due to the fact that it shows the current state of the "FRDO" information system. Based on judicial practice, it was proven that the existence of this resource has not sufficiently resolved the problem of timely access to information about issued documents on education and/or qualifications, training documents. This circumstance hinders the introduction and implementation of preventive measures for recording professional unsuitability for a position (work) due to the absence of the appropriate education and/or qualifications. As a result of the research, it is proposed to take actions to improve the access mechanism to information about issued documents on education and/or qualifications, training documents. It should begin with the requirement to enter information about the mentioned documents into the "FRDO" information system before issuing them to the holders. The registration number of the entry in the register, automatically assigned on the resource, should be indicated on the document forms.
Politics and Society. 2025;(4):80-92
80-92
Big data and artificial intelligence in public administration: opportunities and risks
Abstract
The article is devoted to the analysis of the opportunities and risks of using big data and artificial intelligence (AI) in public administration. The author examines the concept of big data, its key characteristics (volume, speed, diversity, reliability) and ways to process them using AI. The main focus is on the use of AI systems in areas such as forecasting socio-economic development, healthcare, education, combating crime and providing public services. Examples of successful AI implementation in different countries (Singapore, USA, China, Russia, Great Britain, South Korea) are considered. The risks associated with digital bias, cybercrime, privacy interference, social injustice, and the disintegration of social ties are also analyzed. The author emphasizes the importance of regulating the use of AI in the public and corporate sectors, including the legal responsibility of developers, corporations, and government agencies for biased algorithmic decisions, as well as the implementation of ethical standards and user feedback mechanisms. The research methodology includes an expert survey using an online spreadsheet on the Google platform, which allowed 24 representatives of the Russian academic community to be surveyed during October–December 2024. The respondents were leading Russian experts from 16 Russian federal universities representing all 8 federal districts (3 experts from each district). The scientific novelty of the research lies in the systematization of the risks associated with the introduction of big data and AI in public administration, based on an expert survey of leading Russian specialists from 8 federal districts. For the first time, a ranked classification of risks has been proposed, including digital bias, non-transparency of AI solutions, threat to personal data, and possible intensification of social injustice. The article's conclusions emphasize the need to regulate AI algorithms, implement ethical standards, and develop mechanisms to protect citizens from discriminatory decisions. The author emphasizes the importance of testing algorithms for bias, corporate responsibility of developers, and user feedback. The study contributes to the development of the concept of digital public administration, demonstrating a balance between technological capabilities and potential risks from the introduction of AI and big data.
Politics and Society. 2025;(4):93-106
93-106
Information Revolution and the Specifics of Modern Political Science
Abstract
The author examines in detail the relevant issues of the impact of the information revolution on modern political science. The speed of transformation of processes occurring in the contemporary informational world is such that it has a significant influence on all aspects of modern society, primarily in the political sphere. This, in turn, necessitates a relevant theoretical justification for the most likely vectors of development in political science. In this regard, the work explores the approaches of Russian and foreign authors concerning trends and prospects for the development of information and communication systems and their influence on the political life of society and scientific research directions. The author also studies the issues that generate new dependencies and other principles of interaction between political power, the individual, and society. Questions are raised about the transition from a state-centric to a network-centric world. The methodological basis of the conducted research is the inductive method of cognition, based on empirical data. General systems, comparative, and neo-institutional approaches were used for the study. An analysis of practical and theoretical propositions, synthesis of opinions, overview of statistics, and general and specific methods of cognition were conducted. The main conclusions of the scientific work highlight the positive aspects of the informatization process in various spheres of activity. They identify relevant threats associated with the development of information systems and communication means. They determine the prospects for their further transformation as well as their influence on political processes. They provide an understanding that information prompts people to political participation and fosters interaction and understanding among individuals. At the same time, the author concludes about the ambivalent nature of the process of world informatization, the formation of a special value matrix in the virtual computerized environment that directly influences reality, and the emergence of a new, complex-to-understand and embody in real life, information and communication function of the state. This, in turn, proves the necessity for further study of the digital political reality.
Politics and Society. 2025;(4):107-126
107-126
The concept of "Subaltern Empire" in 2024: a discourse analysis of the statements of Russian politicians
Abstract
The article examines the relevance of the concept of «Subaltern Empire», which was proposed in relation to Russia by Vyacheslav Morozov in the book «Russia's Postcolonial Identity. A Subaltern Empire in a Eurocentric World». The author aims to explore the possibility of describing the discourse of Russian politicians using the concept of Morozov, as well as describing Russia's position in the world as a «Subaltern Empire» after the start of a special military operation in 2022. The article examines in detail the statements of members of the Russian political class within the framework of Russia–West relations and, in particular, the current confrontation. The methodological basis of the research is the discourse—analytical approach of Ernesto Laclau and Chantal Mouffe. The empirical basis of the study is the statements of Russian politicians. The analysis used texts of politicians and officials on social networks, the media, as well as official speeches and other political documents. The empirical data covers the period from February 2022 to October 2024. The article concludes that the key features of the concept proposed by Morozov in 2015, remain relevance in the Russian political discourse of 2022–2024. In the confrontation between Russia and the West, the first side is a «subaltern», which is in a «subordinate position» in relation to the «hegemon». The characteristic features of Russia's «subalternity» are the immanent Eurocentrism of political and cultural language, the narrative of frustration and resentment reproduced by Russian politicians, the attempt to construct one's own identity by denying the West, the desire to gain recognition of one's own «merits» in the West, etc. The West is still remains for Russia the significant other with which the latter permanently correlates itself.
Politics and Society. 2025;(4):127-141
127-141
Media in the Era of Algorithmic Control: Transformation of the Ideal of Independence into the Architecture of Network Governance
Abstract
The subject of the research is the transformation of the concept of "independent journalism" under conditions of digital control and algorithmization of the media space. The object of the study is quasi-independent media (BBC, CNN, Deutsche Welle, Al Jazeera), which declare autonomy but, in fact, function as elements of the architecture of network governance of perception. The author examines in detail the mechanisms of media dependence on state and corporate structures, including funding, appointment of leadership, editorial culture, and ideological conformity. Special attention is given to the concept of "algorithmic truth" – a state in which the credibility of information is determined by its visibility in a digital ecosystem controlled by platform recommendation systems, rather than by editorial standards. The role of the media in information wars, the hybridization of media, functional merging with governing bodies, and the mechanisms of projecting soft power through cognitive correction of public consciousness are discussed. The methodology is based on a comparative analysis of international media systems, utilizing approaches from political economy of media, sociology of journalism, and network society theory. Structural-functional and critical-discursive approaches are applied. The scientific novelty lies in the conceptualization of two phenomena: "algorithmic truth" – a state where credibility is determined by visibility in a digital ecosystem rather than by editorial standards, and "network autocracy of perception" – a hybrid form of power where democratic media become unwitting agents of governance through access control. For the first time, it is systematically shown that quasi-independent media (BBC, CNN, DW, Al Jazeera) do not operate as intermediaries but as elements of the architecture of network power, where power does not suppress but programs context. Conclusions: the ideal of independent journalism has lost its significance; freedom of speech has transformed into programmable freedom of perception; traditional mechanisms of democratic control have been neutralized; network autocracy of perception distributes power between the state, corporations, and platforms; algorithmic truth has replaced objectivity; the invisibility of information has become equivalent to its disappearance; the media have turned into a tool for cognitive correction and stabilization of the political order.
Politics and Society. 2025;(4):142-155
142-155
Legal aspects of the use of artificial intelligence in cybersecurity tasks
Abstract
The article examines the legal aspects of the use of artificial intelligence in cybersecurity tasks, including an analysis of the existing legislation of the Russian Federation and international experience. Strategic initiatives such as the National Strategy for the Development of Artificial Intelligence and the program "Digital Economy of the Russian Federation" are being considered. The object of the study is public relations formed in the process of using artificial intelligence in cybersecurity tasks, including interaction between government, corporate and international structures aimed at data protection, preventing cyber attacks and regulating the use of intelligent technologies. The subject of the study is a set of norms governing these relations, including national and international legislation, law enforcement mechanisms, as well as a set of scientific research and ethical principles related to the use of artificial intelligence in cybersecurity. Methodology: The research is based on the analysis of normative acts, strategic documents of the Russian Federation and international law, using comparative legal and systemic approaches. Scientific publications as well as practical cases of artificial intelligence application in cyber security are considered. Special attention is paid to the key challenges associated with the lack of unified standards, the need to protect personal data and prevent abuse when using AI. Strategic initiatives such as the National Strategy for the Development of Artificial Intelligence and the program "Digital Economy of the Russian Federation" are being considered. It is concluded that an integrated approach is necessary, including the development of standards, international cooperation and the creation of transparent law enforcement mechanisms to ensure the effective and safe use of AI in cybersecurity. One of the key elements of solving these problems is the development of ethical standards governing the use of AI. The adoption of the Code of Ethics in the field of Artificial Intelligence indicates the recognition of the need to establish common principles for participants in this process. However, the current document requires detailing and subsequent consolidation in regulatory legal acts regulating issues such as responsibility for the actions of autonomous systems and the use of AI in order to prevent cyber attacks. The AI Code of Ethics should become the basis for the formation of international obligations and national standards, contributing to the creation of a legal space where the interests of the state, business and society are balanced. Without taking these aspects into account, the further development of AI will be accompanied by an increase in risks and a loss of confidence in new technologies, which will inevitably affect national and international security.
Politics and Society. 2025;(4):156-168
156-168
The potential of Muslim religious organizations as subjects of social prevention of radicalism
Abstract
The subject of the study is the potential of Muslim religious organizations as subjects of social prevention of radicalism. The object of the research is the peculiarities of social prevention of radicalism in the Muslim religious environment. In the article, the author examines the content and correlation of the concepts of "radicalism", "extremism", and "terrorism". In this regard, radicalization is characterized as a socio-psychological process, its causes and consequences. Along with this, the peculiarities of the activities of agents of destructive influence are revealed and the possibilities of Muslim religious organizations as subjects of social prevention of radicalism are analyzed. The author pays special attention to the role of primary social prevention in the Muslim religious environment, which can create a kind of "immunity" to radical influences. In this regard, the social functions of religion in general and, in particular, the social functions of Muslim religious organizations are considered. The base of the study was made up of regulatory legal acts and official websites of Muslim religious organizations. The empirical basis of the study are : the results of a case analysis of audio materials of lectures on pseudo-Islamic topics, expert interviews with representatives of the National Islamic Charitable Foundation "Yardam-help". The scientific novelty of the study lies in the fact that the concept of social prevention is revealed in the context of the urgent tasks of preventing radicalism and extremism, its levels are meaningfully characterized, and the potential of Muslim religious organizations as subjects of primary and secondary social prevention is shown. From the perspective of an interdisciplinary approach, a number of measures have been proposed to develop the activities of relevant religious organizations, which should involve reputable Muslim religious figures with extensive experience in socially oriented activities, Islamic scholars, as well as specialists in interdisciplinary research and practice. The results of this work are applicable by political figures in order to improve the social climate, employees of various Muslim religious organizations in order to develop socially oriented activities, teachers and educators in order to educate and enlighten.
Politics and Society. 2025;(4):169-189
169-189
International labor law and international legal cooperation in social security in the construction industry: legal challenges and prospects
Abstract
This article presents a comprehensive analysis of the legal challenges and future prospects of international labor law and international legal cooperation in the realm of social security within the construction industry, particularly within the framework of a multipolar world. Emphasizing the national interests of the Russian Federation, the study examines how disparities in national legal systems impact the protection of labor rights and social guarantees for workers engaged in transnational construction projects. Utilizing a comparative legal methodology, the research scrutinizes international labor standards developed by the International Labour Organization (ILO) and their integration into the national legislations of various countries, including Russia. The scientific novelty of this work lies in identifying the principal obstacles to harmonizing labor conditions and social security standards, which arise from differing national legal frameworks and the divergent interests of states in a multipolar global landscape. Consequently, the study proposes the development of more flexible international legal mechanisms that accommodate national specificities while enhancing the effective protection of workers' rights in international construction endeavors. Special attention is given to Russia's strategic approach to embedding international labor standards into its national legislation, prioritizing its national interests to bolster its standing in the international legal community. Furthermore, the research underscores the necessity of coordinated international efforts to establish unified standards that promote sustainable development in the construction sector and safeguard workers' rights on a global scale.
Politics and Society. 2025;(4):190-204
190-204
Internet subcultures as a tool for transforming the spiritual values of modern youth: challenges, risks, threats
Abstract
The subject of the research is the influence of Internet subcultures on the transformation of spiritual values among contemporary youth in the context of digital culture development. The study examines Internet subcultures as a specific form of network identity based on horizontal communication, meme-based symbolism and digital interaction patterns. It is shown that participation in online communities leads to the rethinking of traditional spiritual and moral orientations, the transformation of behavioural models, and the formation of new forms of symbolic and cultural self-identification. The analysis focuses on mechanisms of value transformation emerging within digital subcultures, including accelerated mediatization, symbolic reduction, multi-layered identity, and normalization of deviant practices. The research also identifies risks associated with toxic, radical and deviant online groups — value fragmentation, distortion of moral norms, decrease in spiritual resilience and risk of radicalization. Particular attention is paid to preventive approaches aimed at the preservation of youth spiritual integrity through the development of digital literacy, support of positive online practices, strengthening of cultural and educational institutions, and creation of a safe media environment. The methodological framework is based on systemic, cultural and sociological approaches, combined with comparative and content analysis of Internet communities, elements of discourse analysis, and axiological assessment tools for evaluating value transformation among youth. The scientific novelty lies in conceptualizing Internet subcultures as a key mechanism of spiritual value transformation in the digital era and in revealing dual effects of online participation: the digital environment simultaneously forms creative potential, social cooperation and new models of civic spirituality, while also producing risks of identity fragmentation, depreciation of moral guidelines and normalization of deviant behaviour. The study clarifies how meme-driven communication, rapid symbolic exchange and multi-vector identity construction redefine the spiritual landscape of youth, weakening intergenerational value continuity and shifting moral decision-making into a situational and emotionally reactive domain. It is demonstrated that risks decrease under conditions of systemic prevention which includes digital competence development, cultural and educational programs, institutional support for constructive media practices and creation of a protective online infrastructure. The findings may be used in educational policy, media education programs and further interdisciplinary research on youth value transformation in the digital age.
Politics and Society. 2025;(4):205-216
205-216
