Nº 12 (2025)
Articles
Two plans of philosophical work: studying the phenomenon and designing its new state
Resumo
The article analyzes and compares research in science and philosophy. It immediately questions the reduction of philosophy to science and the existence of scientific research in philosophy. The features of scientific research are outlined: studying real phenomena, solving problems faced by the scientist, constructing ideal objects, and theoretical discourse. Based on the analysis of five cases of philosophical work (Plato, Aristotle, St. Augustine, Kant, E. Swedenborg), the following characteristics of philosophical work are identified. First, one can distinguish two plans – the formulation and resolution of problems, as well as a unique type of cognition (here, reality is contemplated that does not yet exist in actuality; it is conceived). This refers, on the one hand, to the current problems of a certain culture, and on the other – to the philosopher's problems, who considers these issues as their own. The second feature is that the philosopher, in resolving the problems before them, creates schemes in which solutions to these problems are outlined and constructs ideal objects based on these schemes. The latter allow for the unfolding of theoretical discourse, within which problems are obtained and presented. A necessary condition for this activity is the assignment of reality, interpreted as objects and facts. The objects of philosophical work, unlike the objects of scientific research (natural phenomena – movements of bodies, electromagnetic phenomena, works of art, actions of people, etc.), are not given beforehand; they still need to be formed in the process of philosophical thinking. In both cases, the author suggests distinguishing between the objects of nature or manifestations of objects formed by the philosopher (for example, spirit, reason, action) and the same objects and manifestations when they are viewed (corrected) through the lens of corresponding ideal objects. In his opinion, it is this distinction that Kant grasped when introducing the opposition of “things-in-themselves” and phenomena. In conclusion, it is asserted that after Kant, the conditionality of philosophical work is gradually recognized, on one hand, by the situations and problems of culture, and on the other, by the personal qualities of the philosopher, as well as a unique type of cognition. This inevitably led to a reconsideration of philosophy in the direction of cultural, personalistic, and methodological understanding and interpretation.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):1-13
1-13
Sinicization of Marxism in the Political and Philosophical Doctrine of the PRC in the 21st Century
Resumo
The subject of the study encompasses the process of the Sinicization of Marxism in the political-philosophical doctrine of the PRC in the twenty-first century, examined through the framework of “socialism with Chinese characteristics for a new era.” The analysis focuses on the transformation of categories of historical materialism, including productive forces, production relations, and the people as a subject of development. These categories are treated as applied instruments of modernization, innovative growth, and social equalization. A significant element is the cultural synthesis of Marxism and traditional Chinese thought, which provides a value-based foundation for reform. The study also addresses the relationship between ideology, socio-economic policy, and the narratives of the “Chinese Dream” and the “Great Rejuvenation,” which shape the strategic direction of the course. This understanding makes it possible to interpret the doctrine as a dynamic system integrating philosophical and practical components within contemporary development. The methodological core of the research is the reconstruction of semantic links between historical-materialist categories and their applied function in modern political and administrative orientations. The analytical framework draws on Enfu Cheng’s interpretation of the interrelation between productive forces and production relations, as well as the discursive approach to the study of official political language reflected in the works of Meng Yuifeng, as well as in the research of Meng Yufeng and other international authors. The scientific novelty of the study lies in understanding the Sinicization of Marxism as a coherent applied system in which classical categories are transformed into tools for strategic governance of development. Historical materialism is interpreted as a dynamic method for aligning production relations and institutions with modernization goals. The cultural component – including Confucian ideas of harmony and continuity – forms the value framework of reforms and reinforces their legitimacy. The analysis demonstrates that the “new era” concept integrates economic, social, cultural, and foreign policy elements into a practical model for aligning long-term priorities. The doctrine exhibits integrative potential that ensures the governability of modernization processes. Its structure allows institutional reforms, innovation priorities, and mechanisms of social stability to be connected within a unified conceptual space for sustainable future development.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):14-31
14-31
Ethical gaps in the ethics of artificial intelligence
Resumo
The development of neural networks and their active implementation in various spheres of the economy have raised the challenge of ethical evaluation and legal regulation of the development and application of artificial intelligence (AI) systems. Over the last decade, more than 200 ethical codes and recommendations have been created worldwide, which are actively discussed within the framework of scientific research. The majority of these documents are based on a principle-based approach that sets the boundaries of ethics in the field of AI. This article examines the ethical gaps in artificial intelligence ethics through the development of a multi-level system of strategies to overcome them. The subject of the research is specific mechanisms and strategies for transforming abstract ethical principles into functioning practices at each level. This article discusses the main approaches to addressing issues in artificial intelligence ethics. A systemic approach is proposed as a methodological basis, integrating technical solutions, organizational changes, and legal mechanisms. The applicability of the proposed approach is demonstrated through the analysis of key ethical issues in AI: systematic reproduction of biases, the "black box" problem, distribution of responsibility, the declarative nature of ethical and legal norms, and the challenges of responsibility attribution. For each problem, specific methods of resolution are outlined – from the creation of counterfactual fairness algorithms to checklists for assessing the ethics of AI systems. Conclusions are drawn that a three-level "filter" system is necessary for systematically addressing ethical gaps in AI ethics, which involves differentiating approaches at the development level, organizational changes, creating new principles for state regulation, and a shift in the paradigm of responsibility distribution. The main conclusion of the research is the need for a comprehensive systemic approach, where the rigor of regulation is proportional to the potential harm from the use of the AI system.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):32-41
32-41
On the family of transdisciplinary research and its actual structure
Resumo
The object of this study is modern scientific knowledge, within which, starting from the mid-20th century, there has been an unusual trend developing. Unexpectedly, atypical research that breaks the disciplinary boundaries of classical sciences began to be consistently formed. Recently, they have been categorized as "transdisciplinary." Among the well-known directions of such scientific inquiry are primarily: cybernetic research, systemic and synergetic studies, work within the framework of universal evolutionism, and others. Each of them is associated with the study of some specific "universal" phenomena—properties and regularities of reality. "Universality" in this case means that such properties and regularities are inherent to natural inorganic, organic, and social systems (for example, properties of symmetry; regularities of self-organization). The problem with this new area of scientific inquiry is that such research has long been divided. Thus, the emergence of a whole family of such studies has not yet been noticed, and the new trend has not been explored in its actual fullness. The study employs methods such as analysis, generalization, systematization, comparative method, and analogy method. A new language has been developed specifically for the discussed area of scientific knowledge. The novelty of the research lies in the formation and clarification of a complete picture of contemporary transdisciplinary studies. Some of these studies have not yet been considered at all by the philosophy of science. The actual family of these studies is divided here for the first time into several groups: "generally acknowledged," "shadow systematic," and "shadow particular." New studies are distinctly and unequivocally recorded for the first time using a recently created special unambiguous language. All of this enhances the understanding of what is happening in scientific knowledge. In the future, this basis may allow for the transfer of knowledge from one scientific field to another, less developed one, as well as the discovery of new phenomena. New questions also arise, for example, about what hidden uniformity of reality is revealed and studied by such research?
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):42-58
42-58
Consciousness, Socio-historical being, Culture: on the question of the Formation of the Subject of Speculative Philosophy in Hegel's "Phenomenology of the Spirit"
Resumo
The article offers a holistic analysis of the "Phenomenology of Spirit" as the history of the formation of the subject of speculative philosophy. To this end, the content of the work is divided into three areas, which differ in the way they describe the subject matter (consciousness, socio-historical existence, culture). The authors try to show that it is in the process of mastering their characteristic ways of revealing the content of "experience" that the subject of speculative philosophy is formed. In connection with the specifics of the research subject, it is proposed to distinguish between the structure of the work under study, determined by the structure of its subject, and its composition, the formation of which Hegel correlates precisely with the formation of the subject of speculative philosophy. In this regard, the authors focus on the analysis of the compositional (dynamic) component of the narrative of "Phenomenology", in the process of which they also draw on the historical, philosophical and historical-cultural context of the origin and realization of the idea of Hegel's work. The research is based on traditional methods of historical and philosophical work, as well as elements of structural, comparative and hermeneutic methods. The overall result of the study is the identification of two main transformations of the method of "experience of consciousness" in the "Phenomenology of the spirit." The need for the first transformation is due to the fact that the initial model of the method presented in the Introduction, which is based on the use of internal speech as a criterion for the adequacy of experience, is insufficient to reveal the content of self-awareness. In this case, the philosopher proceeds to describe the modes of self–awareness that develop in the process of activity, the external connections between them that determine the emergence of a new type of subjectivity – social being. The second transformation of the method is conditioned by the need to restore the unity of experience, in connection with which self-awareness, cognizing the socio-cultural content, identifies itself with it and is able to freely generate the same content in the process of philosophical creativity. As a result, the history of culture is reflected in the self-awareness of the subject of philosophical knowledge, a person who recognizes himself as completing the path of the historical development of the spirit.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):59-72
59-72
Critique of Comparative Reason: The Method of Paul Masson-Oursel and the Project of Intercultural Philosophy
Resumo
The article is dedicated to the intellectual legacy of the French orientalist-Indologist Paul Masson-Oursel (1882–1956), one of the founders of philosophical comparativism, which largely anticipated modern intercultural philosophy. Numerous aspects of his philosophical approach align him with contemporary intercultural philosophy. Masson-Oursel justified the necessity of including non-European traditions of thought (Indian, Chinese) in the history of philosophy on equal grounds with European philosophical thought. The article presents the scholar's intellectual biography and analyzes his connections with academic scholars (Henri Bergson, Lucien Lévy-Bruhl, Émile Durkheim, Marcel Mauss, Sylvain Lévy) and with representatives of the non-academic community of Western Europe in the first half of the 20th century (Mircea Eliade, René Guénon). Special attention is given to the analysis of the institutional obstacles encountered by his project of comparative philosophy. The work is based on a historical-philosophical analysis of Masson-Oursel's works, using methods of intellectual history and archival research. Particular emphasis is placed on reconstructing two key methodological tools: "positive analogy," aimed at identifying structurally-functional equivalents in different traditions, and "positive environment," which requires contextual analysis of philosophical ideas. A key source, newly introduced into academic discourse, is an archival letter from Masson-Oursel dated 1945, which vividly demonstrates the institutional resistance to the comparative method in the first half of the 20th century. Based on this, the thesis is substantiated that Masson-Oursel's project, despite its positivist rhetoric and historical limitations, contained a radical critical potential. His program aimed not only at finding universal patterns in the development of thought but also at reconsidering familiar Western categories (such as the opposition between philosophy and religion) through immersion in other cultural contexts. It is shown that this project anticipated key arguments of postcolonial studies and questions of contemporary intercultural philosophy, offering an original combination of positivism with attention to metaphysical experience. An analysis of the reception of his fundamental monograph in the academic community of the 1920s reveals discussions characteristic of that era about the limits of the comparative method. The results of the study are significant for understanding the genealogy of intercultural philosophy and are relevant in the context of contemporary discussions on the decolonization of philosophical knowledge and the overcoming of intellectual provincialism.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):73-87
73-87
Giordano Bruno's Mnemonic System: Analysing the Principles, Purpose, and Practical Use of the Lists in "De umbris idearum"
Resumo
The subject of the research is 10 mnemonic lists presented in the "Art of Memory" section of Bruno's treatise "De umbris idearum" (1582). The author examines each of the 10 lists in detail. The article begins with general information about Bruno's work, a review of literature, and the state of research on the problem. Special attention is paid to identifying the goals and practical tasks of creating the lists and the principles of their formation. The author demonstrates how to use the lists for "memoria verborum". It is explained which techniques Bruno proposed for encoding words that include closed syllables or consonant clusters. The article is accompanied by a translation of the lists from Latin into Russian. Methods: The main research methods are the author's translation of Bruno's lists, the method of historical-philosophical reconstruction, and the hermeneutic method. Results: The original structure of the lists was reconstructed, and the goals of their creation were identified. The main principles of their construction are shown: 1) The 150-line lists are arranged according to a "group of five" scheme and marked with two-letter elements. Each of the 30 "groups of five" has 23 Latin letters, four Greek letters, and three Hebrew letters as the first element. The second element uses a repeating pattern of 5 Latin vowels. 2) The list of characters and the list of actions are divided into "groups of five” indicated by the aforementioned vowels, according to their occupations, from the simplest (agriculture) to science and philosophy. Each " group of five " is led by a "standard-bearer" who is responsible for one of each of the 30 letters of the three-language alphabet. 3) All lists are constructed according to 5 sets of mnemonic elements: 1. characters (agentes), 2. actions (actiones), 3. characteristics (insignia), 4. objects (circumstantia), and 5. additional objects (adstantia). Novelty: In addition to the historical-philosophical reconstruction of the lists, the novelty of the research also includes the first translation of these lists from Latin into Russian, performed based on critical editions of the text, and the provision of clear examples of list usage accessible to the modern reader. The results of the work can be used for further research into the mnemonic component in the works of Giordano Bruno.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):88-124
88-124
The genesis of theoretical knowledge
Resumo
The article distinguishes two stages in the history of theoretical knowledge: 1) the emergence of primary, embryonic theoretical knowledge within pre-theoretical empirical knowledge and according to its inherent laws; 2) the development of this primary knowledge into holistic theories based on established laws of logic and epistemology. The first of these two stages is referred to as the genesis of theoretical knowledge. Philosophers who acknowledge its reality are called aposteriorestists, while their opponents, who assert that theoretical knowledge does not arise from empirical, are called apriorists. The article asserts that apriorism is born from the historical limitations of epistemological research methods. This defines the methodological peculiarity of the article: overcoming apriorism is carried out by bringing the research tools, epistemological concepts, and principles to a working state. Their subsequent application in the research of the genesis of theoretical knowledge is mainly deductive in nature. The article is based on the principles of sequential, Laplacian determinism, according to which all events and states of affairs in the world are necessary. From these principles, it follows that empirical and theoretical knowledge share a common subject, and they represent historically successive stages of understanding this subject. To understand how they succeed each other – and thus solve the problem of the genesis of theoretical knowledge. The goal of the article is to participate in the resolution of this problem. To achieve this, categories – research tools – are introduced and carefully defined: "empirical knowledge," "theoretical knowledge," "thing," "fact," "relation," "ground of relation," as well as the theory of the three worlds by K. Popper, which plays a key role in the article. Using these categories and this theory within the framework of the so-called existential approach, the genesis of theoretical knowledge is presented as the transformation of virtual atomic empirical facts into virtual theoretical ones. Two stages of this process are distinguished. At the first stage, the pure things that are part of the atomic empirical fact are isolated, and at the second stage, the relation uniting them into this fact is derived from the internal content of these things. The methods for solving these two tasks are explored. The role that intuition plays in their solution is emphasized.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):125-140
125-140
The Philosophical Zombie and the Phenomenal Concepts Strategy
Resumo
The paper examines the argument from the conceivability of philosophical zombies proposed by David Chalmers in support of property dualism. According to property dualism, there exist phenomenal properties—subjective characteristics of experience—that cannot be reduced to physical properties. The idea of the irreducibility of phenomenal properties poses a challenge to physicalism, the dominant metaphysical position in contemporary analytic philosophy. The article assesses the plausibility of this argument in light of the Phenomenal Concept Strategy (PCS), employed by so-called Type-B physicalists to defend the claim that the gap between the physical and the phenomenal is conceptual rather than ontological. Two versions of the zombie argument are analyzed in turn: its simplest form and the strengthened two-dimensional version, which takes into account objections based on necessary a posteriori identities. The paper then examines Chalmers’s main argument against the PCS, which confronts its proponents with a dilemma: either the psychological features associated with phenomenal concepts are not physically explicable, or they are incapable of accounting for the unique epistemic status of our access to phenomenal states. The study employs methods of logical-philosophical analysis, including comparative evaluation of arguments, critical examination of thought experiments, and assessment of the logical coherence of competing conceptual frameworks. The paper’s originality lies in its detailed analysis not only of the various versions of the zombie conceivability argument, but also of Chalmers’s principal objection to the PCS. Central to the discussion is a reconstruction of the dilemma this objection poses for the physicalist, along with an analysis of Katalin Balog’s response, which shows that the dilemma rests on a conflation of different modes of description of one and the same fact. The results indicate that the epistemic gaps on which Chalmers relies can be explained within a physicalist ontology by appealing to the distinctive features of phenomenal concepts. The dialectical outcome takes the form of a stalemate: neither anti-physicalism nor physicalism possesses a priori resources sufficient to decisively refute the opposing position. Nevertheless, this result is sufficient, as it allows physicalism to be retained as an internally coherent position, even if it cannot eliminate the intuition of the conceivability of zombies.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):141-157
141-157
"New Phenomenology": the struggle for the renewal of tradition
Resumo
The author discusses attempts to create a new direction in phenomenology, a project known as "new phenomenology." The uniqueness of this project lies in at least two aspects: 1) for decades it has been promoted by a single researcher; 2) in the circles of phenomenologists, that is, those who were recognized as "specialists," "experts," or "disciples," "followers" of original phenomenology, the founder of the new direction was met with significant skepticism for a long time. This skepticism had substantial grounds: some of the fundamental philosophical arguments of Hermann Schmitz, the founder of the new direction, suffered from extreme naivety and were unjust in addressing the philosophers he criticized. The main focus is on the critique of subjectivity in "new phenomenology," as well as the application of a spatial approach to the analysis of everyday experience. The research employs: phenomenological, historical-critical methods, as well as analysis from the perspective of the sociology of knowledge. The article demonstrates the theoretical flaws in Schmitz's arguments, as well as the problems associated with the idea of "novelty" in a philosophical direction such as phenomenology. A distinction is made in the understanding of French and German philosophy. It is shown that the appeal to the idea of "life," as well as radicalism, constitutes a common feature of both variants of the renewal of phenomenology. The reasons for the limited communication between Schmitz's "new phenomenology" and the more traditional study of the phenomenological legacy initiated in the 1940s and 1950s are clarified. It is also shown that a significant obstacle to dialogue with other philosophical directions was Schmitz's commitment to presenting the results of his research in a form close to the language of traditional metaphysics, which diverged from the expectations of world philosophy in the second half of the 20th century. At the same time, Schmitz managed to achieve attention-worthy results: despite all the flaws of the overarching philosophical concept on which "new phenomenology" was based, he attracted the attention and interest of broad circles of specialists in various practically oriented fields of knowledge and activity.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):158-177
158-177
Time, Space, and History in Nishida Kitaro's Philosophy of the 1930s
Resumo
The problems of space and time are among that of meaning-making. They carry paradigmatic approaches that determine the understanding of the world, human being, history, and therefore never lose their significance. The involvement of the East Asian philosophical heritage expands the horizons of research into these problems, opening up opportunities for the search for original solutions and new perspectives of vision. The object of this study is Nishida Kitaro's works from the 1930s, which have so far been only fragmentarily studied and insufficiently addressed in both Russian and Western historical and philosophical scholarship. It was during this period that a number of problems of space, time, and history were specifically articulated and developed by the Japanese philosopher. The study relied on historical-philosophical reconstruction, hermeneutic-textual analysis, as well as contextual and conceptual analysis. General linguistic methods of text translation were also employed, namely, lexical-semantic substitution, grammatical substitution, and interpretation. This article author’s contribution to the field consists in the fact that the peculiarities of the interpretation of such problems as the problem of the correlation of space and time, historical time, eternal present, discontinuity and continuity were considered in the context of the key concepts of Nishida Kitaro of the late period – active intuition, the place of absolute nothingness, self-determination of absolute nothingness, the historical world. The article shows the vectors of transformation in the understanding of spatio-temporal issues by the Japanese philosopher in a comparison of his ideas presented in his early works with the works of the 1930s, relating to the middle and late periods of his activity, consisting in the transition from a “view of the world from the position of consciousness and self-awareness” to a view from the position of an organic part of a self-moving and self-determining world. As a result of the study, the author identifies such features of Nishida's philosophy as absolute presentism, the identification of space and time, the creation of an epistemology of history based on the conception of active intuition and the theory of time as “self-determination of the eternal present.”
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):178-188
178-188
"Language Games" and " individuation": Late Wittgenstein and Simondon against classical dualisms
Resumo
This article explores the methodological and ontological parallels between two key thinkers of the 20th century, whose works offer a radical alternative to the Cartesian tradition. Despite differing subjects of analysis (language philosophy in Wittgenstein and process ontology in Simondon), both philosophers converge in their critique of classical dualisms – subject and object, language and reality, individual and society. The author demonstrates that Wittgenstein’s concepts of "language games" and "forms of life," which emphasize the social and practical nature of meaning, find an ontological complement in Simondon's theory of "individuation" and the "transindividual," which describes the processes of becoming any relatively stable phenomenon. Together, they form a solid philosophical foundation for a non-reductionist analysis of social practices, technologies, and communication, overcoming the limitations of both naïve realism and radical constructivism. The methodological approach of the research is based on the consistent application of complementary methods: comparative analysis to identify structural analogies between the concepts of "language games" and "individuation," as well as conceptual synthesis, which allows for the integration of Wittgenstein's and Simondon's ideas into a single analytical framework. To address specific research tasks, contextual-hermeneutic analysis of the texts is employed, aimed at reconstructing the implicit ontological assumptions of both authors. The relevance of the study is determined by the growing interest in the social and humanities sciences in networked processual and material-corporeal aspects of human activity, which do not fit into outdated subject-object philosophical models. The novelty of the work lies in the systematic comparison of Wittgenstein's and Simondon's ideas, which has so far remained on the periphery of academic discourse. The article contributes to contemporary debates by showing that the synthesis of Wittgenstein's "practical turn" and Simondon's "process ontology" offers a more nuanced toolkit for analyzing modern phenomena – from digital communicative practices and the development of artificial neural networks to ecological and techno-scientific ethics. In this case, action, materiality, and meaning are inextricably intertwined. This approach allows for overcoming the methodological gap between the analysis of symbolic systems and the study of material-technical infrastructures, which is particularly productive for interdisciplinary research.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):189-210
189-210
Inductive theology of Thomas Aquinas
Resumo
The object of this study is the Thomistic concept of rational-theological knowledge. The subject matter is the philosophical logic and methodology of Thomas Aquinas's five arguments for the existence of God. Adhering to Aristotelian epistemology, which posits that all knowledge begins with the senses, Aquinas significantly deepens and expands the scope of its application, thereby forming the methodological apparatus of medieval rational theology. The questions of epistemology constitute a substantial part of Aquinas's philosophy, which has a distinctly scientific-theoretical character. Aquinas dedicates separate chapters not only in his most well-known works – "Summa Theologiae" and "Summa Philosophiae" – to the questions of the conditioning of thought and its nature and mechanisms of cognition. Epistemological issues are also adequately represented in works such as: "Commentary of Thomas Aquinas on Aristotle's Second Analytics," "Commentaries of Thomas Aquinas on Aristotle's Treatise 'On Interpretation,'" and "Commentary on Boethius's Treatise 'On the Trinity.'" The methodology of the research is presented as a combination of general scientific theoretical methods (analysis, synthesis, formal and dialectical approaches), as well as specialized philosophical methods: α) hermeneutic approach (for interpreting primary sources – the texts of Aristotle, Anselm of Canterbury, and Aquinas himself); β) causal analysis (the study pays considerable attention to the examination of the nature of cause-and-effect relationships). Results and scientific novelty. The implementation of this study has allowed for the following findings: α) the relevance of one of the "textbook" philosophical problems of the Middle Ages has been substantiated; β) an authorial systematization and philosophical interpretation of Aquinas's five proofs of God's existence has been presented; γ) the conditioning of the use of the inductive method in natural theology and its scientific advantage over the deductive method has been demonstrated; δ) the principle of applying induction in the pursuit of rational knowledge of God has been revealed; ε) the natural cognitive foundations for constructing Thomistic arguments in favor of God's existence have been identified. The results of the study can be applied as further scientific inquiries in the field of philosophical logic, theory of knowledge, and philosophy of science. The term "theologica," as stated in the title of the article, is borrowed from the eponymous trilogy of the Swiss theologian Hans Urs von Balthasar in the 20th century, dedicated to the problematics indicated in Thomism: how the infinite God can be comprehended in this world through phenomena (immanence), while remaining transcendent.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):211-230
211-230
The synthesis of philosophical traditions in the interpretation of post-nonclassical science
Resumo
The subject of the research is the synthesis of key ideas from continental and analytic philosophical traditions with the aim of forming a new epistemological position that is adequate for understanding the challenges of post-nonclassical science. The object of the research is post-nonclassical scientific rationality, characterized by the complexity, multidimensionality, and value-laden nature of its objects, as well as the active role of the researcher in the process of cognition. The author examines in detail such aspects of the topic as the critique of science for its detachment from the "lifeworld" (E. Husserl), the problem of artificial intelligence and embodied engagement (H. Dreyfus), the essence of technology as "Equipment" (M. Heidegger), systemic materialism and emergent properties of reality (M. Bunge), methodological pluralism and epistemological anarchism (P. Feyerabend), as well as the deconstruction of logocentric foundations of scientific knowledge (J. Derrida). Special attention is given to the integrative role of John Searle's philosophy, whose concepts of biological naturalism and intentionality serve as a bridge between analytic and continental traditions, allowing for the overcoming of the gap between objective description and human experience. The research employs a method of comparative philosophical analysis with elements of a synthetic approach, enabling the integration of various philosophical traditions into a unified epistemological matrix for understanding post-nonclassical science. The scientific novelty of the study lies in the development of an original epistemological position intended to work with the complexity, multidimensionality, and paradoxical nature of contemporary scientific objects. The author demonstrates that the integration of continental and analytic philosophical traditions allows for overcoming the narrowness of one-sided approaches and creating a comprehensive methodology for studying post-nonclassical science. The main conclusions suggest that the synthesis of philosophical traditions forms a qualitatively new epistemological position capable of adequately responding to the challenges of the modern stage of scientific knowledge development. In particular, the proposed approach allows for the effective study of consciousness (combining Searle's biological naturalism with Dreyfus's phenomenology), language (integrating speech act theory with deconstruction), and techno-scientific systems (uniting Bunge's systemic approach and Heidegger's critique of technology). Thus, the article makes a significant contribution to the development of the philosophical foundations of post-nonclassical scientific rationality, offering productive pathways to solving fundamental problems of modern scientific knowledge.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):231-252
231-252
The philosophical and pedagogical legacy of K.D. Ushinsky: relevance in the context of modern educational challenges
Resumo
The subject of the study is the ideas of K.D. Ushinsky, particularly his concepts of nationality, citizenship, and national self-consciousness, considered as ontological foundations for social integration and political identity. The theme of the work is the philosophical and pedagogical legacy of Ushinsky in the context of contemporary challenges: the crisis of collective identities, the erosion of civil solidarity, and the dominance of technocratic paradigms in education. The aim of the article is to conduct a philosophical reconstruction of Ushinsky's teachings, revealing its potential as a resource for understanding and overcoming the relevant socio-political and educational crises of the 21st century. Special attention is given to the interpretation of education not as a pedagogical technique, but as a condition for forming ethically responsible and politically mature individuals, rooted in cultural-historical tradition, yet open to universal values. The methodological foundation of the work consists of historical-philosophical analysis, hermeneutic interpretation of Ushinsky's texts as philosophical statements, and a comparative approach that includes relating his ideas to the concepts of C. Taylor, A. MacIntyre, M. Heidegger, I. Kant, and other thinkers. As a result of the research, it is shown that "nationality" in Ushinsky's view serves as a fundamental structure of social ontology. Ushinsky's pedagogy is interpreted as a form of socio-political engineering aimed at constructing a stable civic community through the synthesis of scientific rationality and cultural rootedness. The results of the study can be applied in the theory and practice of political education, the development of concepts of citizenship and national identity, as well as in the critical analysis of contemporary technocratic education models. The scientific novelty of the work lies in interpreting Ushinsky's pedagogical legacy as an original form of socio-political thought, in which education acquires the status of an ontological and ethical-political condition for the stability of society. The conclusions of the article confirm that Ushinsky's philosophy offers an alternative to both abstract cosmopolitanism and ethnocentrism, forming an ideal of citizenship rooted in cultural soil, yet open to universal values. His teachings maintain heuristic significance for the 21st century as a resource for constructing a morally grounded and politically mature society.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):253-265
253-265
The problem of spiritual growth and public leadership in contemporary society
Resumo
It is hard to find a more controversial and reinterpreted question than the essence of human spiritual growth. Generally understood as an increase in the level of intellectual and ethical development of a person, as well as the awareness of the transcendent aspect in one’s personality, spiritual growth has always been taken for granted in human life, a part of the social worldview, whether in the societies of ancient civilizations, the Middle Ages, the modern era, or even up to the end of the 20th century. At the end of the 20th and the beginning of the 21st century, a unique situation arose in human history: the overload due to interaction with information, caused by scientific and technological progress, began to contribute to a growing alienation from social subjectivity and human nature in general. This alienation is manifested in the spread of the idea of the necessity of technical enhancement of human beings, concepts that disorient individuals in understanding their identity, attempts to be something other than human (the movement of quadrobears), and so on. As a result, the idea of spiritual growth is replaced by the notion of aimless transformation and chaotic multiplication of the diversity of life experiences. Without setting ourselves the impossible task of fully examining the essence and historical understanding of human spiritual growth, we will attempt to describe the contemporary understanding of the content of spiritual growth, the problem of spiritual growth in modern individuals, as well as our vision of ways to address this issue by postulating the idea of spiritual growth through public leadership. The research employed formal-logical methods, analysis, synthesis, comparison, and the specific-historical method of scientific cognition. Despite the "timeless nature" of the question of human spiritual growth, its characteristics in the context of modern realities require further investigation. The main conclusions of the research focus on rethinking the significance of the issue of spiritual growth among the younger generation (in the conditions of a secularized society) and the role of public leaders in conveying the idea of spiritual growth. The author notes that the problem of human spiritual growth in modern society is associated, on the one hand, with the possibility and appropriateness of using artificial intelligence to improve the quality of life. On the other hand, the crisis of spiritual growth stems from the gradual displacement of its very formulation from the topics of upbringing and education, as it is no longer a criterion for recognition and obtaining status in society.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):266-279
266-279
The integral methodology of history in the light of the integral views of Vladimir Solovyov, Rudolf Steiner, and Ken Wilber
Resumo
This article examines the methodology of historical science as a research subject that remains highly relevant and in demand due to its vast development potential and emerging opportunities for historical research. Within this framework, attention is focused on the creation and development of a holistic, or integral, methodology of history. The paper outlines the historiography of historical methodology and offers a retrospective look at various philosophical and religious aspirations for a holistic understanding of reality from ancient times to the present day, which, to varying degrees, have influenced the formation and development of science in general and historical science in particular. Among the most promising systems of holism for historical research, according to the author, are the integral approaches formulated in Vladimir Solovyov's philosophy of total unity, Rudolf Steiner's theory of social tripartism, and Ken Wilber's integral metatheory. A comparative analysis demonstrates the commonalities between the systems of Solovyov, Steiner, and Wilber and demonstrates how their developments can be applied to historical research. The purpose of this paper is to demonstrate that the currently established methods of viewing and understanding history, inherent in various historical schools and auxiliary historical disciplines, can be incorporated into a holistic, or integral, methodology of history, which could unite them all and provide the keys to the intensive development of an integral methodological approach. Based on the research results, the article concludes that the creation and development of a holistic methodology of history based on a synthesis of the integral developments of Solovyov, Steiner, and Wilber will enable a more complete and profound understanding of the past, reduce the likelihood of historical falsification, and, furthermore, will have a pedagogical effect beneficial to the development of both integral historical researchers themselves and the recipients of their work.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):280-301
280-301
Introversion of Public Space: Sound, Light, Thought
Resumo
The relevance of the study is determined by the total introversion of experience under the influence of digital technologies, which necessitates a rethinking of classical philosophical categories. The phenomena of "introversion of sound" (the shift from the concert hall to private headphones) and "introversion of light" (from collective cinema viewing to personal screens) represent not merely a change of media, but a fundamental restructuring of perception and sociality. Concurrently, a migration of thought is occurring – from the public agora to the digital feed, where the oratorical gesture is replaced by publishing activity. Analyzing this triple transformation – of sound, light, and thought – through the lens of the private/public dialectic allows us to diagnose key conflicts and paradoxes of contemporary culture related to personal autonomy, the nature of the social contract, and new forms of alienation. The research is based on historical-philosophical analysis combined with an examination of the transformation of media technologies. The method involves a dialectical understanding of the private/public boundary (Descartes, Kant, Hegel) and a phenomenological description of technological transformations of perception (sound and light) as key mediators of the private and public in the modern world. The author demonstrates how this metaphysics of light and word becomes secularized in modern philosophy, giving rise to the problem of the autonomous subject (Descartes) and his right to the public use of reason (Kant). The key focus of the work is the analysis of the technological "introversion" of perception: sound, striving for maximum public audibility, ultimately migrates into the private space of the personal audio environment, while the light of visual arts, having traveled from public frescoes and collective cinema, becomes inverted and localized in the emitting screens of personal devices. Paradoxically, technologies that expand access to content lead to the individualization of experience and the erosion of traditional boundaries between spheres. Having undergone a process of expansion, the consumption of information from the public sphere begins to take on a private character, while private leisure for its own sake ceases to exist altogether.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):302-311
302-311
Cryptanalytic Techniques in Gregory Bateson’s Anthropology
Resumo
This article offers a new interpretation of the methodological foundations of Gregory Bateson’s anthropology. By examining Bateson’s early visual-anthropological studies of Balinese culture, conducted jointly with Margaret Mead, as well as their later theoretical integration within the synthetic project Steps to an Ecology of Mind, the author argues that the core of Bateson’s approach to cultural analysis is constituted by cryptanalytic techniques. The conceptual bridge linking cultural analysis to cryptanalysis is the notion of redundancy, borrowed from Claude Shannon’s information theory. Redundancy, on the one hand, has a highly specialized application in cryptography and cryptanalysis, as it represents the principal vulnerability of most existing ciphers; on the other hand, for Bateson redundancy is identified with pattern (and with meaning). The use of redundancy in cryptanalysis is in many respects analogous to the way the concept of cultural pattern functions within Bateson’s anthropological framework. The anthropologist’s work thus appears largely as a process of deciphering the cultural code by tracing its internal redundancies. Nevertheless, the author approaches the question of Bateson’s conscious borrowing of cryptanalytic techniques with caution, suggesting instead a certain “inertia” inherent in the conceptual apparatus itself. Invoking redundancy as an analytic instrument almost inevitably entails a cryptanalytic strategy of its application. This situates Bateson’s methodology in opposition to the hermeneutic approach exemplified, for instance, by Clifford Geertz’s interpretive anthropology, in which culture is understood as a kind of literary text requiring the elucidation of meanings. By employing “decipherment” rather than “interpretation” and redundancy rather than meaning, Bateson’s anthropology may be regarded as one of the most formalized approaches to the study of culture and behavior.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):312-332
312-332
The benefits of harm: envy as a moral catalyst in the system of "self-destructive" emotions
Resumo
The article presents an analysis of the phenomenon of envy in the context of its potentially constructive moral significance, despite the prevailing ethical opinion about the "destructive" nature of this emotion. The author demonstrates that the ethical tradition of identifying envy with moral vice does not allow one to see its real impact on a person's moral life, which impoverishes ethical theory. In this connection, attempts at ethical rehabilitation of envy are being considered. The article analyzes the views of Aristotle, who attributed envy to ethically neutral passions, and representatives of classical sentimentalism (D. Hume and A. Smith), who saw it as a natural reaction to social comparison, capable of stimulating competition. The concepts of neosentimentalists are also presented: R. Solomon's theory of "hopeless" envy and its potential for self-esteem, and R. and B. Lazarus cognitive-evaluative theory of emotions, which interprets envy as an adaptive mechanism. At the same time, it is concluded that all these approaches to ethical rehabilitation are incomplete, as they do not take into account qualitative differences in motivation and the consequences of emotional experiences. Further, analyzing the ideas of Rawls the author shows how the classification of envy into general and specific ones contributed to a deeper understanding of its axiological meaning. Along with this, the article pays special attention to the contribution of S. Protasi, who, developing Rawls' ideas, offers a more detailed typology of envy, distinguishing four of its types: emulative, inert, aggressive and spiteful. The author emphasizes that it is the concept of emulative envy that allows us to reconsider the moral status of this emotion, since this form arises when one wants to achieve the same as the other, recognizing his merits and one's ability to achieve. In this case, envy acts as a moral catalyst – it motivates self-improvement and, by helping to understand true desires, promotes personal growth without carrying a destructive component.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):333-343
333-343
The idea of hardiness in the philosophy of Virtues from Antiquity to Early Modern period
Resumo
The philosophy of virtues, being a phraseological part of philosophical knowledge, underwent a significant change from Antiquity to the middle Ages and early Modern period. Socrates, Aristotle, and Plato laid the foundations of the so-called cardinal (civic) virtues necessary for a good life. One of them becomes the main carrier of hardiness – courage, which is the central subject of research in this work. The further development of arethalogy, then pedagogy, psychology and other modern disciplines, and philosophical trends up to the present day repeatedly turns to the idea of hardiness, which is designed to give a person support in a changing world, in borderline existential situations, to find the strength of the spirit and strengthen the body to withstand life's troubles and adequately face death.. Earlier, Modern Periods, having inherited and combined much of ancient and medieval arethalogy, proposed a number of ideas that laid an active foundation in courage, transforming reality, including political. The research methodology is based on the principle of historicism, which made it possible to trace the development of the idea of hardiness through the philosophy of virtues from ancient and medieval philosophy to Renaissance philosophy, to determine the specifics of their perception. The analysis of the discourse made it possible to correlate the terminological component and the context of the word usage of the idea of hardiness. Using the comparative method, the concepts of courage in philosophical and theological systems are compared. An interpretation of the history of the concept of hardiness is proposed within the framework of the philosophy of virtues (arethology), which developed in the Socratic philosophical tradition as courage, one of the main cardinal virtues guided by reason; in the Christian tradition, theological virtues are added, which determine its orientation by faith and hope for divine grace and mercy. The novelty of the work lies in the study of courage as a manifestation of hardiness throughout Antiquity, the middle Ages and the Renaissance within the framework of the dichotomies of that time: body – soul / spirit, mind – passions, inner – outer, active – contemplative life, and state – private life. Depending on the philosophical system, courage manifests itself through a different combination of three basic hardiness strategies: enduring, transforming, and avoiding reality.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):344-357
344-357
Khrushchev Thaw as a Metaphor: An Analysis of Linguistic Mechanisms for Constructing the Image of an Era
Resumo
The paper analyzes metaphorical models that conceptualize the period of the Khrushchev Thaw as a sociocultural phenomenon. The linguistic material born from the era and the variations of its nomination in cultural discourse are considered as repositories of fundamental cultural values and mental characteristics of Soviet society in the late 1950s–1960s. It is acknowledged that the metaphors of the Thaw are directly linked to the changing worldview of the Soviet individual and their response to the relative liberalization of social and political life following the events of 1953–1956. Several stable metaphorical models are fixed in the understanding of the Thaw as a sociocultural phenomenon, with the most widespread being the metaphor "Thaw – a period of Soviet history." Its analysis allows us to assert that the sensitive representatives of Soviet society associated cultural changes with the concept of "thaw" and the metaphorics of the thawing cultural landscape. A key aspect for the identification of the era and the construction of its image in public consciousness is the internal contradictions of the period, manifested in its nomination. The methods used in the research include analysis of metaphorical models, contextual and discourse analysis, elements of a linguocognitive approach, and hermeneutic analysis. The tools of conceptual metaphor theory enabled the application of new approaches to the philosophical understanding of the linguistic material of the studied era. The findings of the publication indicate the relevance of analyzing linguistic expressions for establishing the mechanisms used by society and individuals in the process of comprehending reality and explaining the "nature" of sociocultural phenomena. Thus, the metaphors of the Thaw demonstrate the conceptualization of socio-political phenomena of the second half of the 1950s–1960s in terms related to natural processes of thawing, the onset of unstable warmth, and rising temperature values, thus suggesting more comfortable and safer conditions for human existence. In this context, metaphor serves as a means of reflection and, as a result, the verbalization of feelings of change in the socio-psychological climate of the post-Stalin period of Soviet history through concepts and images associated with the change of season in the temporal cycle.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):358-367
358-367
The Dandy's Ontology of Power in High Society: The Dictatorship of George Brummell
Resumo
In this study, we focus on the key features, principles and values of dandyism, analyze their manifestation in the life and ideas of the first dandy D. Brummell. Special attention will be paid to individualism, audacity and outrage, as well as friendship with certain representatives of high society (especially Prince George of Wales) and ridicule of most of it. We will look at how the dandy interacted with the British society of that time, shaping a unique lifestyle and influencing cultural and social norms. We will analyze the historical figure of Brummel as an aesthete rebel, his attempts to change the perception of beauty and social order represent an important aspect of his legacy, allowing us to better understand the social metaphysics and ontology of dandy power. The paper uses a historical comparative method to analyze the biography of D. Brummell and his ideas in the context of the social and cultural environment of England in the late XVIII – early XIX century. Various sources about Brummel are also compared. The philosophical hermeneutic method is used to interpret the sources. The originality of this study lies in the fact that we study the ontology of power in its non-institutional form, considering the influence on the tastes, fashion and values of certain social groups. Although we rely on the methodology of the French philosopher A. Camus's analysis of rebellion, we focus on the social motive and the specifics of the rebellion, rather than on its existential part. It can be said that D. Brummell established a new order in high society, using outrage, audacity and formal politeness, turning into a kind of revolutionary dictator. His influence combined political and theatrical aspects, where aesthetic norms became analogues of laws. In the role of an artist and lawmaker, he created rules, transforming the traditional foundations of estate society, when representatives of the high-ranking nobility and the rich bourgeoisie found themselves under the control of a person who was formally below them in the official hierarchy.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):368-379
368-379
Styles of calligraphy in Chinese ink painting: the relationship between text and visual image
Resumo
The subject of the study is the calligraphic component of Chinese painting and its dependence on the composition of the image, particularly the motif chosen by the author, in historical dynamics. The object of the research is the interconnections between calligraphic text and Chinese ink painting, including their contemporary development. The author systematically and in detail examines the reasons and principles behind the choices made by Chinese artists of different eras regarding calligraphic styles in painting, from the perspective of artistic-creative, especially compositional relationships, and within the framework of the most popular genres and motifs. The work identifies two main directions of artistic-creative interpretation and the selection of plastic-representational techniques in traditional painting based on the works of several contemporary Chinese painters. The research methodology is based on the systematization and analysis of existing information regarding the history and theory in this field, as well as the study of themes and images that reveal interactions between calligraphic and artistic-representational compositions within works of various genres. The novelty of the article lies in the fact that it reveals a number of artistic-creative characteristics of Chinese painting influenced by calligraphy and its styles for the first time; it establishes the choice of the latter in painting images and motifs across different genres; and it clarifies the nature and compositional relationships between them. The main conclusions are that throughout the prolonged sociocultural development of Chinese art, various methods and styles of writing characters have been formed, which were used, among other things, to enrich the expressive forms of works in painting and aligned with the compositional structure and color scheme of these works, supporting the rhythmic structure in accordance with the artistic intentions of the authors. In contemporary painting, textual inserts and individual characters either enhance the emotional background of the work, serving as a complement to the image and referring the viewer to the traditions of the past, or they become a key element of the image, used by the artist to express their concept. In the latter case, the calligraphic text becomes the main element, subjugating the artistic-plastic components.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):380-391
380-391
Algorithmic "proletarization of the mind": preventive capture of memory and technotragic in the platform society after Simondon and Stiegler.
Resumo
The relevance of this study is due to the total integration of artificial intelligence (AI) systems and platform logic into all areas of social life, which gives rise to a number of acute psychological, social, and political problems—from attention crisis and widespread distrust to the decline of spiritual values. Drawing on the philosophical apparatus of Bernard Stiegler and Gilbert Simondon, the article analyzes how modern technologies based on artificial intelligence not only perform external recording but also carry out "preventive capture of memory." This process, which involves the anticipatory extraction of behavioral data by machines below the threshold of human perception, undermines the very possibility of mental and collective individualization, separating knowledge from bodily experience and exacerbating the techno-tragic condition of modern humans. The methodological approach of this research is based on the synthesis of philosophical analysis of media theory and conceptual deconstruction. At its core is a diachronic analysis of technology, inherited from Simondon and developed by Stiegler, which allows for the tracking of the evolution of proletarianization from the industrial era to the age of surveillance capitalism. Stiegler's pharmacological approach is applied to reveal the ambivalent nature of digital technologies as both "poison" and "antidote." This method is complemented by the conceptual apparatus of contemporary media theory (Alexander Galloway, Eugene Thacker) and in particular, the analysis of "excommunication" and "dark media," which enables the uncovering of new forms of communicative alienation. The method of conceptual innovation is particularly significant—the development and introduction of the term "preventive capture of memory," which serves as a key tool for critiquing the political economy of attention in platform society. The article asserts that the consequence of this is a techno-tragic state, in which the ability to symbolize, creatively participate, and form a common world is lost. Instead of mediation as a condition for the exchange of experiences, the systemic algorithms of platforms implement the logic of "excommunication," generating a closed environment where human participation becomes a byproduct of automated operations. The scientific novelty of this work lies in the development of the concept of "preventive capture of memory" and the synthesis of Stiegler's philosophy of proletarianization with mediation theory to analyze algorithmic subordination as a new form of governance. The future of knowledge and social ties is under threat due to the dominance of entropic models governed by the economics of big data.
Philosophical thought. 2025;(12):392-409
392-409
