Vol 4, No 4 (2025)

Articles

Housing policy of the Russian Federation: main goals and prospects for their achievement

Botkin D.E.

Abstract

the scientific article presents the results of the analysis of the characteristics of the state housing policy pursued by the Government of Russia in modern conditions. The role of the program-targeted approach in achieving the main goals aimed at improving the housing situation for Russian citizens is considered. The tasks set by the Government of Russia in the framework of the implementation of the state housing policy are analyzed. The current problems that have a negative impact on the effectiveness of the implementation of housing policy in Russia are identified. Taking into account the identified shortcomings, recommendations are formed that are aimed at improving the state housing policy of the Government of Russia. The results of the analysis made it possible to formulate in the conclusions of the article the main prospects for achieving the key goals of housing policy in Russia. The implementation of the recommended measures is important to ensure increased efficiency of the housing policy of the Government of Russia and improve the quality of life of the population, including the category of young families. The relevance of the work is due to modern problems in solving housing issues for Russian citizens, which has a negative impact on the quality of life of the population. The object of the article is the sphere of residential real estate in Russia. The subject of the article is the state housing policy of the Government of Russia.
Bulletin of Law Research. 2025;4(4):5-10
pages 5-10 views

Expanding the functionality of the Digital Citizen Profile system as part of the use of a data-centric approach in strategic planning of the human resources potential of the Russian Federation

Zheravov G.G.

Abstract

the development of human resources across key sectors of the Russian Federation is a top state priority. Numerous legislative and strategic initiatives underscore the need to increase the number of qualified professionals in priority fields. The national project "Personnel" and related federal initiatives aim to modernize the labor market and support lifelong education, employment, and skills development. Additionally, other national projects – such as those targeting youth, demographics, digital transformation, tourism, and industrial and agricultural advancement – incorporate objectives for workforce development. However, implementation is hindered by underdeveloped information systems, limiting access to accurate data on individuals' competencies and achievements. This reduces the effectiveness of planning and executing federal and national projects. Moreover, most citizens lack a structured personal development plan and sufficient awareness of state programs that could enhance their professional growth. To address these challenges, the article proposes utilizing the State Information System "Modern Digital Educational Environment" (GISEDO) as a master system, integrated with the Citizen's Digital Profile. This system would collect, store, and analyze data on individuals' education, skills, interests, and achievements. The article outlines the necessary legislative and technological changes to implement this vision and describes how AI and big data technologies could enable personalized development paths, contributing to both individual advancement and national economic priorities.
Bulletin of Law Research. 2025;4(4):11-17
pages 11-17 views

The role of youth movements in Russian political parties in the left segment from 1990 to the present

Shevchenko A.A.

Abstract

the article analyzes the evolution of youth political movements associated with leftist parties in Russia from the 1990s to the present day. Four organizations are being considered: the Leninist Communist Youth Union of the Russian Federation (LKSM RF), the Communist Youth League of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation; the youth wing of the Just Russia Party; and the Youth Yabloko, a faction of the Yabloko Party. The study covers the number of these organizations and the dynamics of its change, their program theses and stated goals, the biographies of key leaders and the stages of their activities, as well as the transformation of ideology and tactics of interaction with the parent parties against the background of political changes in the country. Statistical data illustrating the impact of these youth associations are provided, from their participation in protest actions to representation in government structures. Special attention is paid to the interaction of these youth organizations with political parties, as well as their ability to adapt to the changing conditions of political reality. The study provides examples of successful and unsuccessful campaigns that, one way or another, influenced the promotion of leftist ideas among young people. The analysis was based on media materials, as well as scientific research. Conclusions were also drawn about the role these organizations played in the political socialization of young people, as well as how changes in the Russian political system affected the activity and strategy of leftist youth movements. The dynamics of the participation of these left-wing youth political organizations in various actions and their representation in government structures indicate their uneven influence on the political life of the country.
Bulletin of Law Research. 2025;4(4):18-23
pages 18-23 views

Political discourses in the materials of the journal "Sibirskie zapiski" of the early 20th century: political and textual analysis

Golovinov A.V., Golovinova Y.V.

Abstract

the aim of the study is the political and textual analysis and reconstruction of political narratives in journalistic materials published in the journal "Sibirskie Zapiski" at the beginning of the 20th century. The work is based on published sources – journalistic works published in the journal "Sibirskie Zapiski", in which discourses about the political situation in the country and the Siberian region at the beginning of the 20th century were formed. In the epistemological position, this study is based on hermeneutics, the purpose of which is to interpret test expressions of a posteriori understanding of the surrounding world. Also, the toolkit of political textology had a positive value, on the basis of which it is possible to identify and show political narratives of writers' sources about ongoing socio-political events. The authors found that political discourses in the materials of the journal "Sibirskie Zapiski" had several directions. Firstly, these are the problems of regional policy, the meaning of which was reduced to the ideal of a federal structure of our Fatherland, where the center and the provinces live in complete harmony and unity, based on mutual understanding. Secondly, the political and textual analysis of journalism in this magazine will allow us to highlight the narrative of some ideological differences between Bolshevism and regionalism. Thirdly, the subject of socio-political reflection was the development of land policy and state economy.
Bulletin of Law Research. 2025;4(4):24-29
pages 24-29 views

Tax measures to improve the current anti-crisis policy of the state at the level of state regulation

Tatarnikov I.D.

Abstract

this article discusses measures to improve the current anti-crisis policy of the state at the level of government regulation. The most effective approaches aimed at stabilizing the economy, supporting key industries and improving the social climate are analyzed. Based on the research, measures have been proposed that can improve the effectiveness of crisis management at the state level. The purpose of the article is to analyze tax measures to improve the current anti-crisis policy of the state at the level of state regulation. The research uses methods of analyzing measures to improve the current anti-crisis policy of the state at the level of state regulation. Based on the analysis, it was revealed that it is necessary to implement a tax mechanism to stimulate investment activity in Russia by reducing the VAT rate (by 2-5%) for those enterprises that reinvest more than 50% of profits and increase the volume of investments in industry by almost half. The lost budget revenues as a result of a decrease in their taxation level can be compensated by a slight increase in income tax (by 1.5-2%). The improvement of the indirect taxation system should be based on solving the problem of ensuring sufficient budget revenues by increasing production and consumption, and expanding investment activity.
Bulletin of Law Research. 2025;4(4):30-34
pages 30-34 views

Countering the propaganda of destructive ideologies among Russian youth: a political and legal aspect

Tishkina S.V.

Abstract

the article discusses current issues of countering the propaganda of destructive ideologies among Russian youth from the perspective of political and legal analysis. In modern conditions of globalization and digitalization, the spread of radical and extremist ideas is taking on new forms and scales, which poses a serious threat to the stability of society and the national security of Russia. Youth, being the most vulnerable and susceptible to ideological influence group of the population, requires special attention from the state and civil society institutions. The relevance of the research is determined by the need to improve legal mechanisms and political strategies aimed at effectively countering destructive ideologies. The purpose of the study is to identify the key political and legal tools for combating the propaganda of extremist ideologies among young people, analyze their effectiveness, and develop an author's approach to solving the problem. The concept and content of destructive ideologies, features and channels of influence on Russian youth, political and legal aspects of countering their influence on the younger generation are considered. The approaches of Russian researchers to countering the propaganda of destructive ideologies are defined, and the specifics of Russian youth as an object of influence are determined. The determinants of destructive effects are revealed, promising counteraction mechanisms are identified. The directions of counteraction are substantiated. The methodological base of the research includes comparative legal analysis, content analysis of regulatory documents, and research materials. The author's contribution consists in a comprehensive examination of the problem, taking into account the political and legal context, which allows not only to identify the weak links of the existing system of counteraction, but also to propose specific measures to strengthen it. The author emphasizes the importance of interdepartmental cooperation, improving the legal literacy of young people and developing the system in a preventive manner, justifying the significant role of the state in countering destructive actors.
Bulletin of Law Research. 2025;4(4):35-41
pages 35-41 views

Manifestations of russophobia in the activities of Polish right-wing organizations

Archakov M.K.

Abstract

right-wing political radicalism has always been one of the most important factors in the growth of tension in modern political relations. In the context of Russia's CSR, manifestations of russophobia sentiments have increased in various European countries. Right-wing radical organizations in Poland were among the first to speak out from anti-Russian positions. The study of various aspects of the activities of Polish right-wing radical organizations allows us to explore the conditions and causes of the spread of russophobia in modern Europe.
Bulletin of Law Research. 2025;4(4):42-48
pages 42-48 views

Comparative analysis of the centralized and decentralized management structure of transport systems

Fandyushin M.V.

Abstract

the article is dedicated to a comparative analysis of centralized, decentralized, and hybrid management structures for transportation systems, with a focus on their applicability in the Russian Federation over the long term up to 2050. The aim of the study is to identify the most effective management model to overcome historical lag and ensure sustainable development of the domestic transport industry. In the introduction, the relevance of choosing a management structure as a key factor in the development of socially significant sectors is justified. The author’s tasks are to assess the positions of the scientific community, analyze the historical experience of Russia and the USSR, conduct a qualitative comparison of management systems, and determine the priority model. The main hypothesis posits the advantage of centralized management for eliminating crisis phenomena in the transport sphere. The materials and methods section defines the essence of centralization (control by the central apparatus over all levels) and decentralization (strengthening the role of regions and the private sector). It emphasizes the contentious nature of the issue in academia and the diversity of global practices. The methods used include analysis of normative legal acts, diachronic policy analysis, expert evaluation, and study of open sources. The results include a historical analysis: centralization in the USSR enabled a breakthrough in the development of capital-intensive modes of transport (electric transport, metro), whereas decentralization in the 1990-2000s led to infrastructure degradation and loss of manageability. A comparative table of management systems reveals the strengths and weaknesses of each model. Centralization is effective for resource mobilization and crisis management but is inflexible. Decentralization accounts for local specifics but leads to underfunding and loss of control. The hybrid model combines advantages but is complex to balance.
Bulletin of Law Research. 2025;4(4):49-55
pages 49-55 views

Regional solutions in the field of digital transformation of the public administration system (using the city of Moscow as an example)

Lesaev A.D.

Abstract

digitization of public and municipal services is crucial for modernizing public administration. This task includes two strategic approaches: the creation of "super-services" to facilitate access to everyday tasks and the development of separate services for key government functions. The federal authorities are also paying attention to creating new service options for businesses and citizens. However, the vast territory of Russia and the different levels of digital maturity of the regions create certain problems. Each region has its own unique path of digital transformation, and data integration at all levels of government is a long process. Thus, the improvement of management mechanisms and the use of advanced technologies in public service is crucial for the growth of the digital economy. Current problems in the field of digital transformation of the public administration system also include the imperfection of the legal and organizational framework at the regional level, a small number of strategic documents supporting digital development, as well as insufficient funding and the practical lack of qualified personnel to implement IT projects. The article examines the concept of the national program "Digital Economy" (2019-2024) and "Data Economics and Digital Transformation of the state" (from 2025), defines the goals and objectives of the federal program, analyzes official statistical data on decisions taken in the implementation of the national program for the digital transformation of the public administration system of the city of Moscow, summarizes the results implemented activities.
Bulletin of Law Research. 2025;4(4):56-63
pages 56-63 views

Specific features of regional identity manifestation in a multiethnic constituent entity of the Russian Federation (case study of the Jewish autonomous oblast)

Kashtanyuk V.A., Sheludko A.S.

Abstract

the article examines the features of regional identity manifestation in a multi-ethnic constituent entity of the Russian Federation – the Jewish Autonomous Oblast (JAO). Based on a sociological survey of residents and analysis of scholarly works, the study reveals how the population associates itself with the region, which factors contribute to the formation of this connection, and what keeps people in the area. Special attention is paid to the role of natural and climatic features, historical and cultural heritage, and the sense of "home" as key elements of identity. The conclusion highlights the need for the development of local history studies, cultural practices, and historical heritage to strengthen regional identity. The research findings can be applied in academic and scholarly works on regional identity and local history.
Bulletin of Law Research. 2025;4(4):64-73
pages 64-73 views

Current anti-crisis policy instruments in the Russian Federation

Tatarnikov I.D.

Abstract

this article discusses measures to improve the current anti-crisis policy of the state at the level of government regulation. The most effective approaches aimed at stabilizing the economy, supporting key industries and improving the social climate are analyzed. Based on the research, measures have been proposed that can improve the effectiveness of crisis management at the state level. The purpose of the article is to analyze the current instruments of anti-crisis policy in the Russian Federation. The study uses the method of analyzing current anti-crisis policy instruments in the Russian Federation. Based on the analysis, it was revealed that effective anti-crisis management is possible only with the formulation of an effective system of appropriate tools that will focus on the directions of economic development and perform all the functions assigned to it. The proposed system of anti-crisis management tools requires clarification of the types of assessment and evaluation indicators. By empirical analysis of the available estimates and generalization of their results, we have identified the most significant of them for each direction of development. These assessments can simultaneously be used to justify conclusions about the effectiveness or inefficiency of a particular area of development.
Bulletin of Law Research. 2025;4(4):74-77
pages 74-77 views

A.E. Snesarev's political and geopolitical legacy as an intellectual resource for Russia's strategy in the 21st century

German R.E.

Abstract

in the context of the formation of a new multipolar world order and the intensification of geopolitical competition, a reassessment of classical theories and concepts is taking place. The legacy of the outstanding Russian military theorist, geopolitician, and orientalist Andrei Evgenievich Snesarev (1865-1937) is becoming particularly relevant. His works represent an integral system of views on the nature of the state, war and peace, based on a deep understanding of the inextricable link between politics and geographical space. The article is devoted to the problem of systematization and actualization of the political and geopolitical legacy of A. E. Snesarev for the development of a modern strategy of Russia. Purpose and methodology. The purpose of the study is a comprehensive analysis of the geopolitical and military-political ideas of A.E. Snesarev and the definition of their heuristic potential for modern Russian strategic planning. Among the tasks aimed at achieving the goal: 1) to reveal the understanding of the state in the concept of Snesarev; 2) to reveal the understanding of war as a complex phenomenon; 3) to reveal the importance of "frontier" territories (limitrophs) for ensuring the security of the state. The research is carried out within the framework of the paradigm of political realism and the classical school of geopolitics. The main methods were system analysis, which allowed us to consider Snesarev's ideas as a single concept; historical and comparative method used to compare the geopolitical realities of the early 20th century and the present; as well as content analysis of the scientist's key works. Results. In the course of the research, the key elements of the Snesarev concept were identified and systematized.: 1) understanding the state as a living spatial and political organism; 2) a synthetic approach to the analysis of war as a complex phenomenon where military strategy is inseparable from politics, economics and geography; 3) the concept of strategically significant "frontier" territories (limitrophes) as key areas for ensuring the security of the core state; 4) the establishment of the principles of pragmatism and state expediency, standing above ideological dogmas. Practical application. The results of the study can be used in the activities of Russian government authorities dealing with strategic planning, foreign policy and national security, in particular, in shaping a long-term strategy in Central Asia, the Caucasus and the Greater Middle East macro-region. The materials of the article can also be applied in the educational process in the training of specialists in the field of international relations, political science and military affairs. Conclusions. The political and geopolitical legacy of A. E. Snesarev is a valuable intellectual resource contributing to the strengthening of sovereignty and the formation of a strategy adequate to modern challenges of Russia. His works form the basis for an original Russian school of geopolitics, focused on protecting national interests.
Bulletin of Law Research. 2025;4(4):78-83
pages 78-83 views

EU policy on artificial intelligence: from legal norms to digital transformation of transport

Karimov K.S.

Abstract

the article examines the approaches of the European Union to the legal regulation of artificial intelligence (AI). The author focuses on the analysis of strategic initiatives aimed at the development of AI in the transport industry, such as a Coordinated AI Plan and Innovation Package. Special attention is paid to the interaction of the new law with other EU regulations (GDPR, DSA, etc.), as well as the opportunities and risks of its implementation. The article reveals how AI regulation allows the EU to ensure digital sovereignty, support investment, and guarantee user safety. The challenges faced by developers, users, and regulators in implementing AI in transportation are also discussed.
Bulletin of Law Research. 2025;4(4):84-92
pages 84-92 views

Analysis of the world experience of the state regulatory and legal regulation of electric bus transport

Fandyushin M.V.

Abstract

this article considers the issue of studying the world experience of legal regulation of electric bus transport as a separate type in the transport systems of cities and agglomerations. This type of transport has been actively developing in Russia since 2018, every year the number of cities using it in permanent passenger operation is growing. However, there are gaps in terms of legal regulation of this type of transport, which complicates the process of operating electric bus transport, including from an economic point of view. This analysis is necessary to assess the existing best world practices in state regulation of activities related to the functioning of this type of transport with the subsequent formation of proposals for the implementation of best practices in the domestic regulatory framework. The experience of key global users of electric buses is studied. It is determined that electric bus transport, although initially considered a part of bus transport, currently in most of the countries under consideration has its own regulatory documents allowing to evaluate the assembly process, safety level and quality of operation. Regulatory regulation is not widespread everywhere, but it can be noted: the greater the volume of operation of electric bus transport in the country, the more regulatory documents for this type of transport. The most noteworthy is the positive experience of China in state regulation of individual processes related to electric buses, which can be extrapolated to domestic practice in the future. The collected experience allows in the future to form a domestic analogue of the most significant documents and improve the regulatory and operational processes of electric bus transport in the country.
Bulletin of Law Research. 2025;4(4):93-100
pages 93-100 views

Statehood and rule of Great Bulgaria

Gataullin Z.S., Sakhautdinova L.G.

Abstract

this article is devoted to the issues of formation and activity of one of the states that arose on the territory of the Turkic Khaganate after its collapse. Few states managed to be called great, the political space in question was honored to be called Great Bulgaria. The researchers decided to name Bulgaria so that there would be no confusion with the Bulgaria of Eastern Europe, which, by the dictates of fate, was so distributed by history, modern Bulgaria became the successor of Great Bulgaria. It should be assumed that the greatness of this state is undoubtedly connected with the Turkic Khaganate, it was the nomadic Turks, the steppe peoples who managed to conquer vast territories, unite different peoples, including the conquered ones, into a single and centralized state. The economic and military power and effective management system of the empire served as the foundation for the creation of the successor of the Turkic Khaganate -Great Bulgaria. No matter how researchers of different eras may debate, the role of the individual in the fate of the state cannot be denied. We would like to note the significant contribution of the ruler of Great Bulgaria Kubrat Khan in gaining international recognition of his greatness in this political space. Despite the hostile relations between the Khazar Khaganate, on the one hand, which was imposing Judaism on its state religion, and Byzantium, on the other, which was trying to introduce Christianity, Kubrat Khan managed to maneuver between these two opponents of the Bulgars. We should note the significant contribution of Kubrat Khan, the ruler of the Great Bulgars, to the international recognition of his greatness in this political space. Despite the hostile relations between the Khazar Khaganate, which imposed its state religion of Judaism, and Byzantium, which tried to introduce Christianity, Kubrat Khan managed to maneuver between these two opponents of the Bulgars.
Bulletin of Law Research. 2025;4(4):101-105
pages 101-105 views

Administrative exile in the legal practice of the Russian Empire in the second half of the 19th century

Krasilnikov T.S.

Abstract

the article examines administrative exile as a special legal institution that existed in the Russian Empire. The article notes that administrative exile as a measure of prevention and punishment was formed as part of the development of serfdom and was used for the colonization of Siberia. Despite the abolition of serfdom, the Tsarist government retained administrative exile to Siberia. The article analyzes the main legislative acts of the Russian Empire on administrative exile in the second half of the 19th century. It is stated that in legal practice, administrative exile has been used as a punishment for political crimes and crimes of minor or medium severity. The article concludes that the Tsarist government's widespread use of administrative exile was driven by the idea of "state expediency" in suppressing crime without going through a judicial procedure, which in turn led to the Russian society's rejection of the court's special role in maintaining law and order before the Revolution.
Bulletin of Law Research. 2025;4(4):106-113
pages 106-113 views

State immunity and confiscation of state assets: theory and practice

Prokoplyuk Y.N.

Abstract

the question of state immunity as a public-law entity is particularly relevant in the context of sanction measures imposed by various states. To legally assess the confiscation of state assets in a manner that aligns with established legal norms, it is essential to examine the concept of state immunity, trace its historical development, and analyze the relationship between state immunity and the confiscation of state assets in international legal disputes. The purpose of the article is to study theoretical and practical aspects of the application of state immunity concept in the context of sanctions restrictions, as well as to analyse international and national mechanisms of blocking and confiscation of assets belonging to sovereign states. The study is based on the analysis of international treaties, decisions of international and national courts, as well as doctrinal sources. The methods of comparative legal analysis, systematic approach and case studies are applied. The paper considers key theoretical approaches to defining the boundaries of state immunity and analyses the evolution of the practice of international and national courts with regard to the use of this concept. Based on the analysis of legal documents, court precedents and doctrinal research, the author identifies a number of legal problems.
Bulletin of Law Research. 2025;4(4):114-125
pages 114-125 views

Legal liability for artificial intelligence solutions: international experience and regulation in Azerbaijan

Gatamov B.G.

Abstract

the article analyzes the new problems arising in the field of legal liability due to the rapid development of artificial intelligence (AI) technologies and explores possible solutions. AI is already making decisions in areas such as healthcare, transportation, finance, and others without human intervention, which necessitates a reconsideration of classical legal models. The attribution of legal liability for autonomous AI decisions – whether to the manufacturer, programmer, user, or as an electronic person — remains controversial, and currently, various approaches exist at both international and national levels. The European Union applies a “risk-based” approach, establishing mechanisms for transparency, human oversight, and accountability for AI systems. In the United States and China, regulation is primarily sectoral and tailored to national interests. In Azerbaijan, the legal regulation of AI is still at an initial stage and is mainly based on the existing normative framework. The author notes that the new role of law should be not only restrictive, but also ethical, innovative, and human-centered. The integration of legal and technological knowledge, multidisciplinary cooperation, proactive risk management, and the alignment of national legislation with international standards are highlighted as key priorities for the future. In conclusion, it is emphasized that the legal system must be constantly improved to ensure the safe and beneficial integration of artificial intelligence into society.
Bulletin of Law Research. 2025;4(4):126-132
pages 126-132 views

Responsibility of minors and prevention of offences among them: the concept of state policy of Russia (XVIII – first half of the XIX centuries)

Uporov I.V.

Abstract

this work is devoted to the study of the differentiation of punishments and the prevention of crimes among minors during a rather long and difficult period in Russian history. By examining not only the categories of crimes, but also the transformation of the concepts of "childhood" and "minority," the author concludes that the dynamics of the system of punishments for such offenders are reflected both in legal documents and in legal practice. When raising the issue of the need to establish a special attitude towards minors as subjects of crime, the researcher places the greatest emphasis on the educational aspect, the possibility of correcting children and adolescents, and preventing the commission of such crimes in the future. The author studies the development of the system for preventing and combating juvenile delinquency in Russia, identifying key challenges and issues. The work provides a historical analysis of the dynamics of this process, highlighting the key features of each stage. This research aims to explore the societal attitudes towards juvenile delinquency in different historical periods.
Bulletin of Law Research. 2025;4(4):133-138
pages 133-138 views

The influence of national traditions and customs on the formation of legal norms in Russia

Ashitko N.E., Simakov E.V., Khamidullina V.R.

Abstract

the article examines the impact of national traditions and customs on the formation of legal norms in Russia. The author analyzes the historical and cultural prerequisites for the development of Russian law, with particular attention to the role of customary law, traditional values, and mentality in shaping legislation. Examples of the integration of folk customs into the legal system are explored, along with their significance in contemporary legal practice. The study draws conclusions about the interconnection between cultural heritage and lawmaking, emphasizing the importance of considering national characteristics when developing and improving regulatory legal acts.
Bulletin of Law Research. 2025;4(4):139-145
pages 139-145 views

Согласие на обработку персональных данных

 

Используя сайт https://journals.rcsi.science, я (далее – «Пользователь» или «Субъект персональных данных») даю согласие на обработку персональных данных на этом сайте (текст Согласия) и на обработку персональных данных с помощью сервиса «Яндекс.Метрика» (текст Согласия).