Review of A. Forrest's "Beyond the Edge of the Battlefield. The life of the military during the Revolutionary and Napoleonic wars"
- Authors: Galyamina A.G.1
-
Affiliations:
- Issue: No 5 (2023)
- Pages: 83-89
- Section: Articles
- URL: https://ogarev-online.ru/2409-868X/article/view/373093
- DOI: https://doi.org/10.25136/2409-868X.2023.5.40802
- EDN: https://elibrary.ru/PLLFOI
- ID: 373093
Cite item
Full Text
Abstract
The article analyzes the work of the English historian A. Forrest, devoted to the study of the individual experience of the military during the Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars. Forrest departs from the traditional view of the history of war as the history of battles and focuses his attention on various aspects of the daily life soldiers, such as enlistment, interaction with foreigners during foreign campaigns, captivity, demobilization and the life of veterans after the end of the war. The author pays special attention to the discrepancies between propaganda and the realities of soldier's life and casts doubt on the formation of a new type of revolutionary soldier, postulated by revolutionary propaganda. As shortcomings of the book, one can single out some ignorance by the author of data that contradicts his statement about the complete apoliticality of peasants, who formed the basis of the army of revolutionary France, and their alienation to revolutionary values. Besides the author does not always clearly distinguish the Jacobin army and the army of the Napoleonic time, attributing later features to the former, therefore important details regarding the war nature evolution may be lost. Separately, the author considers the construction of historical memory of the Revolutionary and Napoleonic wars in France.
References
Таньшина Н. П. К 150-летию изучения Французской революции в России: от Герье до Новой русской школы // Новая и новейшая история. 2018. №6. С.118-136. Чудинов А. В. Наш добрый друг Алан Форрест (к 75-летию со дня рождения) // Французский ежегодник. 2021. №54. С. 429-439. Собуль А. Классическая историография Французской революции: о нынешних спорах // Французский ежегодник. 1976. С. 155-170. Гордон А. В. Великая Французская революция: о понятии и понимании // Николай Иванович Кареев: Жизненный путь и научное наследие в трансдисциплинарном контексте современного историознания. Сборник статей и сообщений III Международной научно-образовательной конференции / сост. и отв. ред. Г.П. Мягков. – Казань: Изд-во Казанского университета, 2021. – С. 127–133. Чудинов А.В. Просвещенная элита (к истории понятия) // Французский ежегодник. 2001. С.266-279. Адо А.В. Крестьяне и Великая французская революция. Крестьянское движение в 1789-1794. М.: Издательство МГУ, 1987. Sottocasa V. Résistances paysannes et révolution : le cas des hautes terres du sud du Massif central // Pouvoir locale et revolution. 1780-1850 / ed.R. Dupuy. Rennes: Presse universitaires de Rennes. 1999. P. 377-391
Supplementary files

