Vol 2, No 1 (2021)
PHILOSOPHY
The Historiography and the Politics of Memory
Abstract
The prevailing opinion among the scholars is that history as a study should determine the politics of memory and serve as a model for the narratives of collective identity. However, it should be remembered that memory and history, despite their close relationship, have different goals and realize different functions in society. Historical science cannot define the collective memory, but must participate in shaping the politics of memory. The task of historical politics is precisely to cut off multiplicity in order to provide an opportunity for action, while the task of historical science as a whole is to preserve and increase the potential of multiplicity to provide a wide choice of possible actions.
Respublica Literaria. 2021;2(1):5-13
5-13
Philodemus on the Old Academy (“History of the Academic Philosophers”, col. V–XVI)
Abstract
The paper offers a Russian translation of the portion of the “History of the philosophers” by Philodemus, available in two Herculaneum papyri (PHerc. 1021 and PHerc. 164), which deals with the history of the Old Academy (col. V–XVI, and some supplements). This important source, translated and commented in the article, highlights the most interesting biographical details of the heirs of Plato, Speusippus, Xenocrates, Polemo, Crates, and Crantor, whose activity ranges from 347 to 274 BCE.
Respublica Literaria. 2021;2(1):14-27
14-27
Does contemporary analysis of difficulties with Zeno sequences contain a solution to the dichotomy?
Abstract
We analyze contemporary thought experiments with some Zeno objects and infinity machines. We show how the method of reasoning from J. Hawthorne’spaper helps to understand the structure of one of the refutations of a rather sophisticated version of Zeno’sof Elea Dichotomy. After that, wepropose an improvement of this version of the Dichotomy. Further, weshow that the method of operating with infinite sequences of conditional sentences – proposed in J. Hawthorne’spaper – is insufficient to refute the last variant of the Dichotomy.
Respublica Literaria. 2021;2(1):28-36
28-36
Fuzzy Type Theory in the Analysis of Argumentation
Abstract
The article deals with a fazzy variant of P.Martin-Löf’sintuitionistic type theory. It presents the overview of fuzzy type theory rules and an example of its application to the analysis of the persuasiveness of argumentation. In the latter, the truth values of fuzzy logic are interpreted as degrees of persuasiveness of statements and arguments. The formalization is implemented in the proof assistant Agda.
Respublica Literaria. 2021;2(1):37-47
37-47
The Role of the Concept of Performativity in the Context of Indirect Communication Research
Abstract
The article traces one of the lines of influence of the analytic philosophy of language on the humanities, in particular, on linguistics – the line that is associated with the perception of the concept of performativity and the corresponding view of language in studies of indirect communication. The distinction between illocutionary and perlocutionary speech act formulated by J. Austin is applied to the case of indirect communication, as a result of which it is concluded that the performative properties of language can manifest themselves not only in illocution, but also in perlocution. It is shown that many examples of indirect communication function like performatives – the concept of an indirect performative is introduced to denote them – and can be described from the point of view of a performative approach.
Respublica Literaria. 2021;2(1):48-61
48-61
Philosophical Davos as a Reason for Divorce. M. Fridman’s Version. Part 1
Abstract
The paper analyzes the intellectual situation that developed in the 1920s, which led to what later became known as a philosophical split into two directions – continental and analytical philosophy. The author poses a problem: was this a split associated with the division of philosophy into scientifically oriented philosophy, on the one hand, and metaphysics, on the other? Or is this division quite controversial? Using the example of a famous episode, a philosophical discussion between Е. Cassirer and M. Heidegger in Davos in 1929, the author discusses another split in philosophy: into the so-called classical way of philosophizing based on spiritual tradition (represented by E. Cassirer) and the so-called non-classical, represented by M. Heidegger. In this regard, the topic of the development and overcoming of the neo-Kantian tradition, the topic of understanding the basic ideas of the philosophy of I. Kant, but in a new cultural situation is discussed. In his analysis, the author proceeds from the version proposed in the book by M. Friedman: “Philosophy at a Crossroads: Carnap, Cassirer and Heidegger”.
Respublica Literaria. 2021;2(1):62-83
62-83
SOCIOLOGY
Place and role of ethnic traditions in the sociocultural space
Abstract
The article analyzes approaches to the study of sociocultural space, with a focus on the potential of the concept of “social space” in ethnosociological research. Its most important components have been identified: social and cultural space. The specific function of social space is fixed, namely, the preservation of the structure of social institutions, within which social interactions take place. When analyzing the cultural space, it was shown that cultural specificity is most clearly manifested in ethnic cultures (ethnocultures), the semantic core of which is tradition. The author comes to the conclusion that the totality of social and cultural processes is localized within certain territorial boundaries and is a socio-cultural superstructure over the landscape and climatic space. Spatial development of territories is possible in a situation of maintaining the meaningful uniqueness of the cultural space (realized, first of all, in traditions) within the boundaries of a single social, legal and economic space. social space determines, to a certain extent, the universality of the form (through social institutions and structures), and cultural space determines the content specificity of the sociocultural space.
Respublica Literaria. 2021;2(1):84-94
84-94
Influence of Ethnic Identity on Representations About Interethnic Integration: To Statement of the Problem
Abstract
The author fixes the main trends associated with the study of the phenomena of ethnic identity and interethnic integration in social philosophy and identifies gaps that could be filled by expanding of their interpretation. It is recorded that in a significant part of the research, the phenomena are considered separately. Thus, ethnic identity is expressed as a one-dimensional parameter, part of the “identification matrix” of an individual. Studies devoted to interethnic integration are often aimed at identifying mechanisms for achieving an abstract desired image – a multiethnic community with a high degree of integration of its members, who clearly and most often unambiguously realize their ethnic identity. Despite the obvious interrelation of the phenomena under consideration, there are very few studies, dedicated to the influence of ethnic identity on interethnic integration. It is shown that it is important to rethink the phenomenon of ethnic identity in terms of its fluidity, multiplicity, fragmentation, non-reflection, complexity as a basis for the formation of ideas about strategies and ideas about acceptable for the individual mechanisms of interethnic integration. It is also relevant to study the influence of ethnic identity on the ideas of interethnic integration in the multiethnic communities of modern large cities.
Respublica Literaria. 2021;2(1):95-103
95-103
Global and local: socio-cultural aspect
Abstract
The article deals with the problems of socio-cultural changes associated with globalization processes. The sociocultural approach explains the trends in the transformation of the sociocultural space, sociocultural environment. In the context of globalization, a paradigm of nonlinearity, locality in the sphere of sociocultural life is being formed. One of the main tools of globalization is sociocultural expansion, which contributes to the unification of sociocultural development. The combination of the global and the local in the evolution of the sociocultural sphere creates a dual situation in the anagenesis of the sociocultural space. Globality enhances the impact of liberal-modernist values. Locality favors the preservation of the influence of traditional and conservative values. The vector of socio-cultural development of Russian society has not been determined.
Respublica Literaria. 2021;2(1):104-117
104-117
INTERDISCIPLINARY RESEARCH
Phenomenology of Cinema in Philosophy of Postmodernism
Abstract
The article focuses on the issue of phenomenon of cinema in works of Jean-Francois Lyotard, Henri Bergson, Roland Barth, Michel Foucault and Jean Baudrillard. Postmodern methodology allows one to view cinema as a “deconstruction” of both cultural and socio-political discourse. Based on the analysis of the works of philosophers, the author generalizes the phenomenological characteristics of the cinema of postmodernism, such as the hypnotic ritualism of cinema; devaluation of metanarratives; and appeal to the absolute “banal” and “hyper-realities”. It is noted that the spread of postmodern tendencies in modern cinema is manifested in drama, imagery, stylistics, montage and other components of the creative process. The author concludes that Jean-Francois Lyotard, Henri Bergson, Roland Barthes, Michel Foucault and Jean Baudrillard have laid the foundations for understanding the unity of philosophy and cinema in the modern world.
Respublica Literaria. 2021;2(1):118-128
118-128
SCIENTIFIC LIFE
Socio-Humanitarian Knowledge in the Digital Environment
Abstract
The article presents an overview of the speeches of the participants of the All-Russian Scientific Conference "From idea to practice: Socio-humanitarian Knowledge in the digital environment", held in Novosibirsk Akademgorodok on March 24-25, 2021. The leitmotif of the speeches of the conference participants was the idea of cooperation and interdisciplinary interaction of representatives of natural science and socio-humanitarian areas in the conditions of the formation of the digital environment.
Respublica Literaria. 2021;2(1):129-136
129-136

