Aleksandr Bogdanov’s Concept of Revolution and the Organisation of State

Cover Page

Cite item

Full Text

Abstract

The article is devoted to the controversy of Alexander Alexandrovich Bogdanov, the so-called “another Bolshevik”, with Lenin and his associates on the question of the revolution and the ways of building a socialist society and state. It is shown that Bogdanov expressed a critical attitude towards the revolution and its socialist nature, the ability of the proletariat to play a decisive role in it, and wrote about Russia’s unpreparedness for an anti-capitalist coup, thereby expressing a distinctly marked anti-Leninist position. Based on the analysis of a large corpus of Bogdanov’s works, the authors focused their attention on the following aspects of his work relating to the theme of revolution: the contradictions between Bogdanov and Lenin in its interpretation even before October 1917; Bogdanov’s views on the revolution and real socialism after its completion; his interpretation and evaluation of “war communism”; the program for building socialism in the USSR and the search for ways to form fundamentally new social structures developed in the context of the science of tectology, created by him; Bogdanov’s project “Proletkult” and his utopian novels, in which he foresaw how “socialism in one country” would be built and how the transition from the old exploitative to new forms of human coexistence would be carried out, as well as the danger of the degeneration of democracy into a dictatorship.

About the authors

Tatyana Rumyantseva

Belorusian State University

Author for correspondence.
Email: t.rumyan30@gmail.com
ORCID iD: 0000-0001-5893-9852

Doctor of Philosophy, Professor, Department of Philosophy and Social Sciences

4, Nezavisimosti Av., Minsk, 220030, Belarus

Daniela Steila

University of Turin

Email: daniela.steila@unito.it
ORCID iD: 0000-0002-1374-5699

PhD, Professor

20, via Sant’Ottavio, Turin, 10124, Italy

References

  1. Williams RC. The Other Bolsheviks. Lenin and His Critics 1904-1914. Bloomington-Indianapolis: Indiana U.P.; 1986.
  2. Nevskij VI. Dialectical materialism and the philosophy of dead reaction. In: Lenin VI. Materialism and empirio-criticism. Critical notes on a reactionary philosophy. 2nd ed. Moscow: Gosizdat; 1920. (In Russian).
  3. Susiluoto I. The Origins and Development of System Thinking in the Soviet Union. Political and Philosophical Controversies from Bogdanov and Bucharin to Present-day Re-evaluations. Helsinki: Suomalainen Triedeakatemia; 1982.
  4. Novik IB, Uemov AI. Bogdanov AA, Tectology. Voprosy filosofii. 1990;(11): 172-174. (In Russian).
  5. Grille D. Lenins Rivale. Bogdanov und seine Philosophie. Köln: Wissenschaft und Politik; 1966.
  6. Scherrer J. Ortodossia o eresia? Alla ricerca di una cultura politica del bolscevismo. In: Scherrer J, Steila D, editors. Gor’kij-Bogdanov e la scuola di Capri. Una corrispondenza inedita (1908-1911). Roma: Carocci; 2017. P. 17-200.
  7. Bailes KE. Lenin and Bogdanov: the End of an Alliance. In: Cordier AW, editor. Columbia Essays in International Affairs. New York-London: Columbia U. P.; 1967. P. 107-133.
  8. Ballestrem KG. Lenin and Bogdanov. Studies in Soviet Thought. 1969;9(4):283-310. https://doi.org/10.1007/bf01044079
  9. Haupt G, Scherrer J. Gor’kij, Bogdanov, Lenin. Neue Quellen zur ideologischen Krise in der bolschewistischen Fraktion (1908-1910). Cahiers du monde russe et soviétique. 1978;19(3):321-334. https://doi.org/10.3406/cmr.1978.1332
  10. Jensen KM. Beyond Marx and Mach. Aleksandr Bogdanov’s “Philosophy of Living Experience”. Dordrecht: Reidel; 1978.
  11. Scherrer J. Les écoles du parti de Capri et Bologne: la formation de l’intelligentsia du parti. Cahiers du monde russe et soviétique. 1978;19(3):259-284. https://doi.org/10.3406/cmr.1978.1321
  12. White JD. From Karl Marx to Bogdanov. Co-existence. 1978;15:187-206.
  13. Scherrer J. Bogdanov e Lenin: il bolscevismo al. bivio. In: Storia del marxismo. II: Il marxismo nell’età della Seconda Internazionale. Torino: Einaudi; 1979. P. 493-546.
  14. Biggart J. Anti-Leninist Bolshevism. The “Forward” Group of the RSDRP. Canadian Slavonic Papers. 1980;23(2):134-153. https://doi.org/10.1080/ 00085006.1981.11091662
  15. Gorzka G. A. Bogdanov und der russische Proletkult. Theorie und Praxis einer sozialistischen Kulturrevolution. Frankfurt a.M. - New York: Campus; 1980.
  16. Yassour A. Lenin and Bogdanov: Protagonists in the “Bolshevik Center”. Studies in Soviet Thought. 1981;22(1):1-32. https://doi.org/10.1007/bf00837970
  17. Mänicke-Gyöngyösi K. “Proletarische Wissenschaft” und “sozialistische Menschenheitsreligion” als Modelle proletarischer Kultur. Zur linksbolschewistischen Revolutionstheorie A.A. Bogdanows und A. A. Lunacharskijs. Berlin-Wiesbaden: Harassowitz; 1982.
  18. Yassour A. The Empiriomonist Critique of Dialectical Materialism: Bogdanov, Plechanov, Lenin. Studies in Soviet Thought. 1983;26(1):21-38. https://doi.org/10.1007/bf00832209
  19. Yassour A. Bogdanov-Malinovsky on Party and Revolution. Studies in Soviet Thought. 1984;27(3):225-236.
  20. Sochor ZA. Revolution and Culture. The Bogdanov-Lenin Controversy. Ithaca-London: Cornell U. P.; 1988.
  21. Soboleva M. Aleksandr Bogdanov und der philosophische Diskurs in Russland zu Beginn des 20. Jahrhunderts. Zur Geschichte des russischen Positivismus. Hildesheim-Zürich-New York: Olms; 2007.
  22. Steila D. Science and revolution. Reception of empirio-criticism in Russian culture (1877-1910). Moscow: Akademicheskij proekt; 2013. (In Russian).
  23. Bogdanov AA. Tectology. General organizational science. Moscow: Ekonomika; 1989. (In Russian).
  24. Bogdanov AA. Problems of socialism. Moscow: Politizdat; 1990. (In Russian).
  25. Bogdanov AA. Empiriomonism. Articles on philosophy. Moscow: Respublika; 2003. (In Russian).
  26. Bogdanov AA. Faith and Science. Voprosy filosofii. 1991;12:27-91. (In Russian).
  27. Bordjugov GA, editor. Unknown Bogdanov. Vol. 1-3. Moscow: AIRO-XX; 1995. (In Russian).
  28. Moiseev NI. Bogdanov's Tectology: modern perspectives. Voprosy filosofii. 1995;8:8-13.
  29. Bonch-Bruevich VD. Geneva memories. Pod znamenem marksizma. 1929;1:18-46.
  30. Bogdanov AA. The fall of great fetishism. Moscow: Navstrechu revolyutsii; 1910. (In Russian).
  31. Trocky’s letter to Gorky M. 20 (7) June 1909 [letter]. In: Scherrer J, Steila D, editors. Gor’kij-Bogdanov e la scuola di Capri. Una corrispondenza inedita (1908-1911). Roma: Carocci; 2017. P. 458-463. (In Italian).
  32. Bogdanov’s letter to Gorky M. After 21 (8) June 1909 [letter]. Gorky in the mirror of the era. Unpublished correspondence. Moscow: IMLI RAN; 2010. P. 66-67 (In Russian).
  33. Brandist C. The Dimensions of Hegemony. Language, Culture and Politics in Revolutionary Russia. Leiden-Boston: Brill; 2015.
  34. Krementsov N. A Martian Stranded on Earth. Alexander Bogdanov, Blood Transfusions, and Proletarian Science. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press; 2011.
  35. Bogdanov AA. World crises, peaceful and military. Letopis’. 1916;7:214-238. (In Russian).
  36. Bogdanov AA. The path to socialism. 2nd ed. Moscow: Novaya Rossiya; 1917. (In Russian).
  37. Bogdanov AA. The tasks of the workers in the revolution. Moscow: Typ. Ya. G. Sazonova; 1917. (In Russian).
  38. Biggart J. World War and World revolution: interpretation by Alexander Bogdanov. In: Belykh AA, editor. Economists on 1917 revolution. Moscow: Delo RANKhiGS; 2021. P. 585-616. (In Russian).
  39. Mjasoedov BA. Heretic of Marxism. Mir novoj ekonomiki. 2015;2:100-112. (In Russian).
  40. Bogdanov AA. The fate of the workers' party in the present revolution, P. 1. Novaja zhizn’. 1918 January 26 (February 8):19(233). (In Russian).
  41. Spinoza. Tractatus theologico-politicus. London: Trübner & Co., 60, Paternoster row; 1862.
  42. Bogdanov AA. The fate of the workers' party in the present revolution, P. 2. Novaja zhizn’. 1918 January 27 (February 9):20(234). (In Russian).
  43. Gloveli GD, Figurovskaja NK. Tragedy of collectivist. In: Bogdanov AA. Questions of socialism. Moscow: Politizdat; 1990. P. 3-27. (In Russian).
  44. Buldakov VP, Kabanov VV. “War communism”: ideology and social development. Voprosy istorii. 1990;3: 40-57. (In Russian).
  45. Pljutto PA. Bogdanov AA on “war communism”. Sociologicheskie issledovanija. 1990;11: 147-151. (In Russian).
  46. Lenin VI. About food tax. The meaning of the new policy and its conditions (1921). In: Collection of works. Vol. 43. Moscow: Politizdat; 1977. P. 205-245. (In Russian).
  47. Dudley P, editor. Bogdanov’s Tektology. Hull: Centre for Systems Studies; 1996.
  48. Bogdanov AA. Red Star. The First Bolshevik Utopia. Bloomington-Indianapolis: Indiana U. P.; 1984.
  49. Bogdanov AA. No need to mislead. In: To all comrades!. Paris. 1910. P. 1-5. (In Russian).
  50. Bogdanov AA. About proletarian culture. 1904-1924. Leningrad-Moscow: Kniga; 1924. (In Russian).
  51. Steila D. A Proletarian Encyclopédie. In: Di Salvo M, Kaiser DH, Kivelson VA, editors. Word and Image in Russian History. Boston: Academic Studies Press; 2019. P. 90-117.
  52. Mally L. Culture of the Future. The Proletkult Movement in Revolutionary Russia. Berkeley: University of California Press; 1990.
  53. Lenin VI, Plekhanov GV. Against Bogdanov A. Moscow: Krasnaja nov’; 1923. (In Russian).
  54. Plekhanov GV. Against Bogdanovshchina. Khar’kov: Proletarij; 1925. (In Russian).

Supplementary files

Supplementary Files
Action
1. JATS XML

Согласие на обработку персональных данных

 

Используя сайт https://journals.rcsi.science, я (далее – «Пользователь» или «Субъект персональных данных») даю согласие на обработку персональных данных на этом сайте (текст Согласия) и на обработку персональных данных с помощью сервиса «Яндекс.Метрика» (текст Согласия).